The wall

tolerance modified modified

“Don’t you dare,” she said in a voice, “start your day that way.”

It was the usual. Pre-dawn. Alarm playing Lucinda Williams. Stretch, reach for the iPad and moderate a few comments before waking the dog up. But today there was an issue. In a rare event, Dorothy had actually been reading this blog then, recklessly, she strayed into the nether regions of the comments section.

“I can’t believe you read half that stuff,” she added, “let alone publish it. The least you can do is talk to me in the morning before you start at it again.”

As usual, she was correct. Surveying the digital detritus that floats in overnight, usually from the West Coast, is no way for a man to start a day. Even the wizened owner of a famously pathetic blog with a history of seeking public abuse. Spousal control is definitely in order.

Lately, if you’ve noticed, this site’s been the dumping grounds of a mess of people who blame others for their own inability to buy a house. They’re angry. That’s become hate. And it’s a short trip then to prejudice, bigotry and racism – when hate’s focus grows wider and impersonal. The targets are immigrants, especially from China. Particularly rich ones. But it extends to Syrians and refugees as well. And now to Asian folks who may have lived in Canada for generations.

So the attackers generalize in a way that becomes bizarre. All wealthy immigrants must be crooks, money-launderers or criminals, for example. They don’t pay taxes, or try to integrate and destroy neighbourhoods. They employ slaves back in China, and are importing communism. In the last few days I have allowed comments calling them vermin, insects and scum – giving you a brief glimpse of what I see when I open my eyes to each morning.

At the heart of this resentment, emotion and hostility is real estate. How sad is that? No higher principles involved. No ideals or values to fight for. Nothing noble or moral. Just stuff. Not only does everyone in this country think they have a right to own a house, and in the best of hoods, but they seriously resent the idea all immigrants don’t come here struggling. It upsets the social order.

Well, I get that things have changed. Most countries no longer have walls around them, which certainly helped our nation achieve a higher standard of living than it would otherwise. But globalization has crushed some the norms of the past. Old jobs migrate. Money flits around. People move. Yesterday I gave you examples of Canadians changing the face of Arizona real estate. What came back was a torrent of fearful disgust at Chinese house-buyers in Vancouver. In this country we suck and blow with finesse.

Well, we’ve also hit a wall. I’ve had it.

John, in Ottawa, sent me this: “As a middle aged white guy, first generation Canadian, I cannot believe some of the racial comments posted. I’m sure that if the ethnic backgrounds of the “complainers” was researched, 99.9% of them would have had “immigrants” somewhere not too far up the family tree.

“I have worked with many ‘people born elsewhere’, and each and every one was hard working, and really proud to be Canadian. Each and every one of them thought of themselves as Canadian first, as my parents did. Please keep your blog going, and please, somehow, keep your moderator’s hat on.”

Shortly before his note arrived, I texted my wife about shuttering this site. A comment had just arrived from Vancouver warning that I am “a dangerous traitor and need to be strung up” for deleting racist, anti-Chinese comments or saying immigration is not to blame for the fact everyone can’t live on the Westside. ‘Had enuf,’ I said. ‘Let’s elope.’

It’s tempting. In the past eight years I’ve written 2,283 articles and moderated 412,039 comments. I’ve sold no ads, taken no subscriptions or donations. Made no money, on purpose. The goal was always to try and assist others in their own lives. Most people respond by being respectful, thoughtful, useful. A growing number are, well, assholes.

This cannot continue. And won’t. There are enough blogs and news sites around whose owners don’t seem to care how high the sewage seeps. In a world where it’s all about clicks and traffic, they’ll post anything. But not here. We’re done.

Expect more deletes. Abusers will have their IPs blocked from accessing the site. And, as a final solution, I will email your mom.

If you live to hate people, start your own damn blog. If you want me to choose between this site and my wife, just keep it up.

458 comments ↓

#1 HAM on 03.29.16 at 6:02 pm

I enjoy your blog, a lot of what you have to say is very insightful and what most have NOT been talking about.

I don’t agree with you when you downplay the impact of HAM in Vancouver, but are we supposed to agree about everything? I think not.

Thanks for all you do and I really hope that you keep it up!

Cheers.

#2 ILoveCharts on 03.29.16 at 6:03 pm

I love the blog. Keep it going. People need to grow up and learn to separate an analysis of foriegn cash from their opinions of foreign people. We’re a country of immigrants all squatting on land we took from the first nations. Diversity and respect are cornerstones of this country.

I love my neighbours from all countries and ethnicities in YVR.

Building on yesterday’s post: Even if foriegn purchases represent only 5% of transactions, they can make a noticeable impact – particularly if they are high-end purchases that have a trickle down effect and also if they go on to rebuild new houses creating jobs.

Things are tightening up in China with respect to capital outflows. We are seeing the short term rush of capital out but it is not sustainable.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-28/swiping-cards-800-times-way-to-beat-china-s-money-outflow-curbs

#3 Gary in Kelowna on 03.29.16 at 6:05 pm

Don’t shut it down Garth. The majority of us really appreciate your efforts. I have learned and benefited from your financial expertise and philosophy over the years of reading your books and Blog. Thanks.

#4 Andy on 03.29.16 at 6:05 pm

It’s not like a racist or a xenophobe was born from reading your blog Garth. At least you are drawing them out. Mature adults would have to read and decide for themselves.

Please, please keep the blog going! Your efforts and persistence are much appreciated! Thank you.

#5 common sense on 03.29.16 at 6:05 pm

Jesus..I have now seen everything.

I am good friends with Lucinda Williams and to see her name on this blog is just too damm freaky….

Did you see her in TO last week garth?

#6 Unhinged Loon on 03.29.16 at 6:06 pm

First for God Emperor of Mankind Trump.

#7 mishuko on 03.29.16 at 6:07 pm

Well said.

I almost feel sorry for the losers. Almost.

I for one appreciate every word here.

#8 Vundo on 03.29.16 at 6:08 pm

Garth: Thank you for this blog and for standing up to those racist thugs. As much as I like throwing my two cents in wherever I go, would you consider continuing to write with the comments completely disabled? I would prefer that to no blog at all and I doubt I am alone.

#9 common sense on 03.29.16 at 6:10 pm

No room for hate anywhere…hopefully this hating on other’s of a different race,etc isn’t the shape of things to come. yet…

People are indeed scared, mainly due to the fact people have put themselves in bad financial shape and someone ELSE has to be blamed.

Huge debt loads, people not getting what they have been sold to expect since childhood, less job prospects, older demographics and lower growth…and we’ve only just begun.

Choose people. I’ll take Garth over hatred anyday.

Mark can start a new blog. That’s it!

#10 northerngirl on 03.29.16 at 6:12 pm

I don’t understand why Canadians blame foreigners…it’s our own government and system that make it easy for foreigners. But I guess it’s always easier to blame the “other”.
BTW, Garth, it is because I’ve started reading this blog that I started investing (and made money even during the downturn). I can’t thank you enough. You and Dorothy are gems this society needs.
;)

#11 YVRTechGuy on 03.29.16 at 6:14 pm

I don’t think the YVR bubble has any more oomph left in it. I work in high-tech in Vancouver, and seeing the change clearly. A few years ago everyone wanted to live in the YVR area, any job that was posted had people applying from all over the world. Now, the jobs sit empty, no applicants from outside the area. Billion-dollar projects are being cancelled or moved elswehere. In the team I work with, all the age 40+ folks who already own family homes will be retiring off over the next 5-10 years. Everyone else, in the <40 crowd, every single family I know is now looking to leave town. These are skilled engineers, wealth-creators, the backbone of the economy, all earning $100-170k with countless more ancilliary and support jobs, the bread-and-butter of the income and corporation tax base … all making plans to leave.

#12 Old stock Canadian on 03.29.16 at 6:15 pm

Josh Gordon is assistant professor and Anjum Mutakabbir is a master’s student at Simon Fraser University’s School of Public Policy
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/rob-commentary/data-on-canadas-housing-market-is-fine-but-we-need-action-now/article29407997/
One such solution is to impose a progressive property surtax on homes over a given threshold and allow homeowners to deduct this tax against their income tax. Provisions or exemptions could be developed for residents who are retired. This would target the tax squarely on foreign buyers who make little or no income in Canada. But here’s the beauty of this proposal: If foreign money isn’t playing a large role in affordability, then prices will be unchanged, we’ll receive modest revenue from these wealthy foreign owners, and the tax will be a wash for Vancouverites. But if foreign money is playing a large role, significant revenue will be collected and affordability will improve as these investors choose to put their money elsewhere and/or sell their holdings. Either way, the vast majority of Vancouverites win.

Insane idea. Prohibitively costly to manage, plus demonstrably unfair as it links income and property value. Just what you’d expect from a masters student. — Garth

#13 Tenugi0 on 03.29.16 at 6:15 pm

Best post so far this year Garth, thanks!

#14 HellYeah on 03.29.16 at 6:16 pm

In my opinion, the bigots and racists shouldn’t live in our country’s biggest (most expensive) cities anyway. I assume they can’t appreciate the diversity and culture that comes with being a destination for everyone from immigrants to the First peoples. Love yr neighbour or yr going to karma hell.

Haters gonna hate.
Potatoes gonna potate.

#15 Frank on 03.29.16 at 6:17 pm

For Vancouver haters: head to vancouvercondo.info it allows racism and bonus, they hate Garth already! The one good side is they have local sales data posted daily.

Don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out.

#16 Bill Grable on 03.29.16 at 6:18 pm

I hope you can find the time to keep doing this great blog.

Ignore the morons and carry on.

So many of us really have learned a lot.

The great writing is much appreciated.

#17 JohnP on 03.29.16 at 6:18 pm

Garth Think of the mental health of your loyal readers before you do anything brash.
This firestorm reminds me of what my native friend said recently, “immigration is ruining this country”

#18 The end must be near on 03.29.16 at 6:20 pm

Ok, thought I’d seen it all and that the bubble was nearing an end. You know what they say “when the last bear throws in the towel”.

First it was:
Vancouverpricedrop.com (hasn’t posted in a while — weren’t too many price drops apparenlty);
Whispersfromrainforest dude;
VREEA guy

Say it isn’t so Garth. Keep it going. We’ll behave.

#19 Alero01 on 03.29.16 at 6:22 pm

Thank you for this post, Garth. The hatred within the comments posted on your blog is almost palpable. Over time, I have noticed that the posters who I most enjoyed reading have simply stopped posting comments, which were for the most part reasonable, thoughtful & insightful. Even if I did not agree with those posters, I didn’t feel that they were being racist & hateful bigots. I can only assume that the posters who I enjoyed have decided to limit their exposure to the “new crew” that have decided to make this blog their home. I would hate to see you shut down this blog. However, after reading this particular post, I would understand your reasons for doing so if that is your final decision.

#20 Sixtyfourk on 03.29.16 at 6:23 pm

The obvious solution to your problem is to disable comments.

Many sites have been forced to do that for the very reasons that you outline.

I think if asked, most blog-dogs would rather have you turn off comments than shut down the whole thing.

#21 Lisa Lisa on 03.29.16 at 6:23 pm

Where’s the hate, Garth? You are one of the meanest spirited bloggers I have yet to come across.

For the sake of the tfsa, you asked bloggers to vote a despotic govt. back in. You have done nothing but insult t2, as you call him, since he was elected. You speak glowingly of Mulroney??

You are condescending and intolerant of those who don’t share your views. And as far as your views go on Asian money, they have nothing to do with a sense of fairness. Since when did you become a social justice warrior anyway?

So your own readership ripped you a new one yesterday. Tough bounce. You want to take your ball and go home??

DO IT.

#22 Scott on 03.29.16 at 6:24 pm

Just close the comments section.. I stopped reading this crap half a year ago anyways!

#23 JimmyD on 03.29.16 at 6:24 pm

I don’t post a lot (or really at all) but I do read your blog daily. Thank you for the constant upkeep. I saw no blog all day on Sunday and I was like “well, Easter. Fair enough.” When I woke up the next morning I checked out the sight and BAM. There was one Sunday. You are a machine.

Anyway, please keep posting. How else am I going to know that I’m doing everything wrong?

#24 A man about a dog on 03.29.16 at 6:24 pm

Garth, I messaged you the other day thanking you for the blog and education. But I cut my comments short.

I had a message for the readers. There are very few places on the web that you can go to get advice without being sold something. This blog is free and breaks down every finance topic to something I can understand.

You responded to one bitter sockeye salmon yesterday (who talks big game but still hasn’t posted his pics):

You mean I won’t lie for profit? What a shock. — Garth.

And this comment sums up exactly why I keep coming back. Not too many places can be trusted like greaterfool.

Your approach appeals to me, not because you say what I want to hear. But because you say what is real and can be backed up with stats.

So to all the bitter blog dogs. If you want someone who will tell you what you want to hear and confirm your bias. There are plenty of them out there.

#25 Andres on 03.29.16 at 6:24 pm

Garth, please don’t let the freaks influence your choices with this great blog. The comments are only a minuscule fraction of your actual traffic (as I’m sure you already know), and the crazy racists are just a fraction of the commentators. I hope you can shake it off and keep this going.

#26 Appreciative on 03.29.16 at 6:26 pm

Garth,

Don’t blame you or Dorothy (or beloved Canines) for getting discouraged by moronic comments – but please don’t let all the fantastic educational service you provide get diluted by the rantings of Neanderthals. As another commenter has suggested, how about taking a “mini-break” by just posting your same excellent comment, but just disabling the comments for a while (or always)? I sometimes read the comments on your blog, but only in the same way that I sometimes read public bathroom graffiti – out of mere morbid curiosity. I wouldn’t miss the comments at all, but I would sure miss the valuable service you provide. Keep up the great work! :)

#27 Former Fool on 03.29.16 at 6:26 pm

Garth,

I don’t comment often but I am thankful for your blog. I read it everyday, even when I am traveling. It is entertaining, informative, and has opened my eyes to a world that I didn’t know even existed. Please continue to keep this blog going; many of us appreciate what you do (for free I might add!).

Also, do not waste your time moderating those with hateful comments. There are people in this world that feel entitled to everything and are angry when they don’t get it. You should put more wear and tear on your keyboard’s delete key; it’ll cost you a new keyboard once in a while but it will be well worth it.

Best Regards,
FF

#28 Brett in Calgary on 03.29.16 at 6:26 pm

I have only been reading your blog for about 3 months, but everyday I tell my wife the latest financial news I learned on “Garth’s blog”. You provide valuable information which helps non-financial specialists like myself make better informed decisions. Recall, 38% of Canadians don’t know how to contribute to a RRSP- that says everything to me about how informed the average Canadian is. In other words, not very informed and probably more likely to blame than learn. Holding a mirror up for us to see how ugly we’ve become can make you unpopular at times, Garth. After all, selfies are the mirror of the future but we can edit those on our phones so they look better. To conclude, you should keep writing, because for every racist nob there are 10 good people you are helping.

#29 Milla on 03.29.16 at 6:26 pm

First, when anyone starts a sort of a teaching he shall be ready for any kinds of followers. They could be nice or curious or nasty . This is just normal. Second, few words about racism. With 100% confidence I can say that my former Russians/Soviet Union residents who buy property all over the word above million dollars are using criminal sources. Why I am sure? Because during 75 years of this country existence we were under such a control that we were not able to have more than a couple thousands of national currency on our accounts. And all this crazy money in rich Russians possessions that magically appeared on their accounts of course are stollen. I would say reloaded from state pocket into the private pockets on very high government level. Sorry, Garth, with your Canafian honesty it is probably impossible to digest. But it is truth.

#30 acdel on 03.29.16 at 6:27 pm

Hey Garth, always love your blogs but I think that you and the wife should purchase a few bottles of wine and take that nice long deserved vacation.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-29/billionaire-koch-brother-will-sell-20-000-bottles-of-wine

#31 Western Pete on 03.29.16 at 6:28 pm

Thanks for the blog Garth, it has helped me and possibly thousands of people and I hope it can for years to come!

Hopefully those angry people will get the message and tone it down / find something more productive to do. For sure they are only a tiny part of your readers…

A blog with no comments would be better than no blog, your writing style and humour are unique :)

#32 conan on 03.29.16 at 6:28 pm

Don’t give up Garth! I love your site.
I too noticed that you do not put any ads on your blog but also thought that this site would act like a giant client magnet for your financial services gig.

It is a very nice way to get around DNC. Then again, you were always very smart.

Not that smart. — Garth

#33 Fred on 03.29.16 at 6:28 pm

Don’t shut it down Garth…..I might end up getting lost in a bidding war and buying a house if you do. Don’t let the realtors win.

#34 We are more the same than different. on 03.29.16 at 6:29 pm

Perspective and view is dependent upon where you are standing. If you were a millionaire a few times over, you would park your money where it’s easy to park as well if you were fearful of the current regime, wanted fresh air, good education for your children etc.

These views and perspectives will change pre-bubble, during bubble and post bubble. Everybody sings a different tune under different circumstances.

Grow up and accept.

#35 Victoria Real Estate Update on 03.29.16 at 6:29 pm

Keep up the good work Garth. You’ve helped many Canadians, I’m sure, even though you may not hear about it.

Don’t let those who want you to give up win. What you write is valuable to many.

#36 William Bell on 03.29.16 at 6:34 pm

First the BBC ended Top Gear, now this blog is going too.

Please do not shut down this site.

The house pumping group now knows how to turn off one of the few logical voice in sociality.

On the plus side it’s riding season, let’s take the bike cross country and just pause the site for the summer. You should see there’s still be a good amount of people that cares.

#37 Lead Paint on 03.29.16 at 6:34 pm

Why would anyone get upset by Hot Asians… (what does the M stand for)?

It’s your blog Garth, delete and restrict to your heart’s content, you’ve more than proven you tolerate a lot more crap and abuse than you should.

#38 ed on 03.29.16 at 6:34 pm

RE #1 HAM, & #2 ILoveCharts

OMG; the stupidity, the turbidity–“I like your blog Garth but let me just be racist here.” I must now decide to either a) no longer read the comments section, or b) leave the human race for Mars or somewhere more conducive to life.

#39 catalyst on 03.29.16 at 6:35 pm

While I think the true story is unknown since debt service according to rbc is greater than 100% of incomes (how are the approvals happening) it would be refreshing to see the comments focused on another topic until something noteworthy happens.

Personally I’d love to hear your opinions on euro zone and moreally macro economic views as history is being reshaped as we speak.

#40 Johnny on 03.29.16 at 6:36 pm

I think you stated at some point that 95% of visitors don’t read the comments section. Hence, only a negligible minority comes here to read/publish comments. As this section doesn’t enrich the content and takes a tremendous amount of your time, the solution is simple: stop allowing comments.

#41 JSquared on 03.29.16 at 6:36 pm

Thank you, thank you, thank you Garth!! I love your blog, just discovered it over a year ago. You are doing a great service for so many people who’ve been brainwashed by the establishment, giving them an alternate way of looking at life & finances. It’s a selfless endeavour to share your insight, on a daily basis, for free. I just found it a shame your comment section had been hijacked by a subset that took away from any quality that might have been used to share useful information. It got to the point I couldn’t even stomach reading the comments section anymore, total waste of time. Always wondered why you allowed it. For those who seemed to have made this blog their personal social life (kind of pathetic if you think about it), perhaps it’s time to move on and actually go get a life.

#42 Mrs. Potato on 03.29.16 at 6:37 pm

Hey Garth! Please don’t shut down the blog. I have found your advice invaluable, especially for a young 25 year old female trying to navigate the house lust out here in the west coast. Had it not been for you, my husband and I would have put 5% down on a cheaply built condo just to get into the market! Today, we’re debt free and have almost maxed out our TFSA and RRSP contribution rooms. So believe me when I say your work is greatly appreciated out here.

I do agree that you should moderate your comments more. I’ve always thought that words would never faze me, but being a recent immigrant with a not-so-white skin tone, I’ve started to dread the comment sections of blogs that make the slightest mention of housing and immigrants. With all the nasty comments being thrown around, I’m beginning to wonder if most Canadians really feel that way about me (us) while pretending to be nice to me (us) in person. I start to imagine that one of my coworkers could be one of the angry commenters on here saying all sorts of awful things about us new-stock Canadians, then smiles at me and pretends to be happy I’m here. Scary thought….

By the way, I’m extremely proud to be Canadian (almost – I’m still a permanent resident), I’ve put work into integrating, and no, I haven’t bought a house in YVR with dirty cash from my home country.

#43 Victoria Real Estate Update on 03.29.16 at 6:38 pm

# 18 The end must be near

There seems to be plenty you don’t understand about real estate.

Examples:

1. That supply/demand conditions in any housing market can change quickly from favouring sellers to favouring buyers.

2. That the price performance of one month can’t be used to predict the price performance of the next month.

We’ve seen this before in Victoria and we’ll see it again. Supply/demand conditions are always temporary.

Here’s a chart that should remind you of what’s happened in Victoria’s recent past.

VICTORIA’S RECENT PRICE DECLINE

. . . . . . . Single Family Home Prices. . . . . . . . .
. .Percent Above/Below May 2010 Price Level. . .
. . . . . .x = Toronto, * = Victoria (City). . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+25%. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . x. . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+20% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+15%. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .x. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+10% . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+ 5%. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
….0%. . . x*. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
– 5%. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .*. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
-10%. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .*. . . .
——————————————————————————
. . . . . . .May . . . . . . . .May. . . . . .December.
. . . . . . .2010. . . . . . .. 2012. . . . . . .2013. . .

(sources: indices of Victoria’s R/E board, Toronto’s R/E board)

The price data for Victoria (City) was taken from the local board’s frankenumber price index so the price plunge that it shows (11.7%) was likely significantly deeper and prices probably continued to fall well into 2014. Any price improvement that may have happened since then would be far less than what the frankenumber price index shows.

Prices across Greater Toronto gained 22.0% over the same period of time.

#44 WallOfWorry on 03.29.16 at 6:39 pm

Garth…any comments on Yellen’s address today? Looks like maybe only 1 rate hike this year, with Q1 GDP projecting coming in at .9%? The Fed is looking a little foolish when some members are suggesting that they just need to get to it and raise rates while the Chair is urging extreme caution?

#45 Ultraman on 03.29.16 at 6:39 pm

It would be a shame to shut it down now. The fun is just beginning. You have no choice though to moderate hard. ZH used to be a great site with intelligent, pertinent comments and discussions. Not anymore, just the garbage that you mentioned. ZH is mostly irrelevant now. Don’t let that happen to GF.

#46 Chris on 03.29.16 at 6:43 pm

I appreciate your advice, and admire your courage, persistence and faith. But if you were to throw in the towel, I wouldn’t blame you. Things are happening that are beyond comprehension. Somebody should write about the Canadian economy. Something went wrong somewhere along the way. Why did the big name Canadian companies fail and what is coming, other than Walmart on every corner. Is immigration stimulating or dragging down the economy?

#47 John on 03.29.16 at 6:43 pm

Love this blog! The good, the bad and the ugly.

#48 Dr. Bill Gamble on 03.29.16 at 6:43 pm

All good things come to an end as they say! But hopefully not too soon. Thanks for the advice over the years Sage Old one! And The Rule of 90 will live on far beyond all our years!

#49 tundra pete on 03.29.16 at 6:44 pm

Thanks for the blog Garth. As to all the racist comments, you idiots need to get a life and remember whose blood might one day save your ass. You might be surprised.

The only thing I hate more than animal abusers are rapists and racists. Ironic how similar those words are isn’t it? If I ever had to deal with either of those, no law enforcement would be needed. Problem would be taken care of with little delay.

As it pertains to this blog, if you can’t afford the West side or any part of Vancouver, then buy where you can afford. If you are going to be racist then stay off this blog. If you ever abuse an animal, you better hope I’m not around.

#50 Milos on 03.29.16 at 6:45 pm

Hi Garth,

I am not sure how much this e-mail will change anything but please do not give up. You are helping all the people who are willing to educate themselves and make the right/smart moves in life. I am an immigrant and I would love these haters to say stuff to my face. It would be my pleasure to re-educate them fast. It is amazing how some people have no need to self-reflect…..EVER. I know you are a tough guy and you have a very “twisted” sense of humor which quite a few of us appreciate. You also keep a portion of this nation sane since we are surrounded by greedy idiots who unfortunately have the right to talk and express their opinion daily (that last part kills me). Stay tough, stay strong…you have my support and respect.

#51 Irish Stew on 03.29.16 at 6:45 pm

Hatred because others are successful – only the NDP could join that parade……and it seems Trudeau now too.

Garth – the notes are appreciated.
My grandparents were Irish and Belgian immigrants who came here w/ nothing. Our family was built on hard work and now are successful financially, but more important, also socially .

Could care less if the Asians are buying Vancouver – if you want more money – go make it on your own and work hard like the forefathers before you!

#52 Jemm on 03.29.16 at 6:46 pm

The older I get the weirder the exchange of ideas has
become. Today everyone feels their opinion is needed and wanted on virtually every topic going. If you feel the comments on your blog are particularly harsh you should see what is going on everywhere else. Twitter idiots included. Hiding behind a keyboard and being able to express whatever comes into a pea sized brain is the norm these days. Personally I don’t wish to read what just every idiot has to say. Its just become to easy to pen a reply to everything written. Sometimes a moment of thought would improve the ideas but probably not. DELETE AWAY but keep up the good work.

#53 Mark on 03.29.16 at 6:46 pm

“Mark can start a new blog. That’s it!”

Mark has even less tolerance for the xenophobic, “let’s blame the Chinese for high Vancouver/Toronto RE” crap that appears on this blog daily than even Garth. If you think Garth is bad for censuring a few people who overly promulgate theories of “yellow fever”, you ain’t seen the iron fist of Mark, that’s for sure.

Now, the jobs sit empty, no applicants from outside the area.

Yeah a good rule of thumb for an entry-level professional historically has been for their annual salary to be 1/3rd that of local housing prices, and mid-career, 1/2 local housing prices. With those numbers, one can accumulate a bit of savings, have a house, and send their kids to college.

But when even engineers and lawyers are out-gunned by mere Realtors in the local housing market, well, that’s definitely not the makings of a sustainable society.

Don’t know why you’d have trouble finding workers in ‘high tech’ in Vancouver though. Reputable firms are still receiving mountains of resumes for engineering positions in Vancouver. There’s still plenty of people willing to make sacrifices.

#54 April. on 03.29.16 at 6:47 pm

I selfishly wish you to continue with this blog, but death threats these days are not to be taken lightly. I’ll keep reading as long as the blog is here – it has been very valuable to me, thank you. However – safety and sanity first.

#55 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 6:48 pm

Ever since the election the Wacked out lefties have invaded the comment section. Rabid rasists entitled victims.

It’s that much fun anymore.

#56 For those about to flop... on 03.29.16 at 6:48 pm

#18 The end must be near on 03.29.16 at 6:20 pm
Ok, thought I’d seen it all and that the bubble was nearing an end. You know what they say “when the last bear throws in the towel”.

First it was:
Vancouverpricedrop.com (hasn’t posted in a while — weren’t too many price drops apparenlty);
Whispersfromrainforest dude;
VREEA guy

Say it isn’t so Garth. Keep it going. We’ll behave.

//////////////////////////

It’s funny you should mention Vancouver price drop as I was thinking about that site when I wrote my post calling for calm this morning.

When visiting that site ,two other sites were mentioned, Craiglist rants and raves ,which I only visited once was full of hatred and racism and the Greaterfool which I consider mainly to have some bright commenters and a couple of putzes.

I chose to shun the hatred and now check in on Garth and some people I refer to as blog brothers/ buddies.

I actually refuse to use the words ‘blog dogs’ out of respect as calling someone a dog where I am from is extremely derogatory.

Usually when I write a comment and hit submit I have a smile on my face ,when I wrote this mornings post I actually winced ,It hurt writing that and I feel some pain in the bosses writing tonight.

He’s right,there are other blogs to get your fill of that stuff,leave me here with my blog brother and sisters…

M41BC

#57 I'm stupid on 03.29.16 at 6:49 pm

If you do decide to stop posting please do it over time. I really enjoy reading this blog, im kind of addicted to it. So ending it with a bang would be like quitting crack over night.

#58 Sebee on 03.29.16 at 6:49 pm

Garth, seriously. How about a vacation? How about 3 days a week? No big deal if you want to reduce your stress. Plus why moderate so quickly? Why even have a comment section? Why not comments once a week only? Isn’t your time precious? There is easy middle ground to save your time and stress. Comments on Wednesdays only!

#59 Neo on 03.29.16 at 6:50 pm

There’s an old african saying “A falling tree makes more noise than a growing forest.”

I’m among the majority, who read your blog daily without commenting. We’re thankful for your work. Please don’t give up because of a few annnoyinghaters

#60 Blogbitch on 03.29.16 at 6:53 pm

There are those of us who simply roll our eyes and emphatically refrain from joining in the comment frenzy. And we are legion. We can even afford cauliflower.
Keep deleting.

Illegitimi non carborundum!

#61 Gonkman on 03.29.16 at 6:54 pm

Garth,

Don’t let the haters win… I would rather your blog with no comments section then no blog at all if it comes to that.

You shouldn’t have to deal with these “People” and that is unfortunate.

Between the haters, gold bugs, tin foil hatters and angry lefties the comment section has become a lot more like a toxic comment dump. Maybe it’s time to close down the dump for a while.

Maybe they will “go away” after a few months and you can re-open the comments dump again. Right now you are correct though and people have been getting out of line.

I don’t know what I would do without my daily info and Comic Photos. My kids even get a kick out of the good “comic dog photos”.

Just don’t shut it down completely… Long live The Greater Fool!!!

#62 Mooshee on 03.29.16 at 6:55 pm

Wish there was a way to thank you for your time and commitment. Your sacrifice is not going unnoticed and is deeply appreciated. Don’t give up. Thank you!

#63 Casey van p on 03.29.16 at 6:55 pm

Enjoy the blog very educating and entertaining.
Usually I just scan the comments read Garths comments.
They are by far the best. Cheers

#64 bb on 03.29.16 at 6:56 pm

You’ll read all these blaming on every Canadian site with a comment section – Migrants (driving house prices up and stealing jobs), wealthy Asians (driving house prices up), Temp foreign workers (sending money out of Canada thereby destroying the economy), Government (for not taking care of them), capitalists and entrepreneurs (for being greedy and not pay a living wage) etc… I wish Garth wouldn’t delete the comments here so we can all read em.

#65 baddog on 03.29.16 at 6:58 pm

Garth your blog is the only one that I read on a daily basis. Please don’t let a few anonymous jerks ruin things for the rest of us. We love you man. Peace.

#66 Peter on 03.29.16 at 6:59 pm

Hi Garth,

As a 30-year old millennial, I’ve learned a lot from this site. I hope to keep doing so for many months. While I admit that I was house horny for quite some time, your advice has cooled some of the desire until I’m in a more sustainable financial position. I’ve also started focusing more on long term compound goals rather than worrying about my next car. Keep up the good work.

#67 For those about to flop... on 03.29.16 at 7:01 pm

#33 Fred on 03.29.16 at 6:28 pm
Don’t shut it down Garth…..I might end up getting lost in a bidding war and buying a house if you do. Don’t let the realtors win.

//////////////////////////////

Hey Fred that’s why we stole your car keys so you couldn’t do anything stupid.
I guess you could always catch a bus to the bidding war,but you would lose your intimidation factor.

Found your car keys yet?…

M41BC

#68 Pixel on 03.29.16 at 7:02 pm

Just shut down the comments section and save the work it takes to moderate it. Nobody reads your amazing blog for the comments, and I’ve never read any useful comment anyway. Keep up with the amazing advice, thanks!

#69 The greatest fool.ca on 03.29.16 at 7:03 pm

Garth, just set it up so posts from B.C. Are automatically deleted. Easier.

#70 Russ on 03.29.16 at 7:04 pm

Here’s one for our new dog “Boom”

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6E74I-LkkMg

And to all,
life does hit you hard bro

Cheers, R

#71 Don Watson on 03.29.16 at 7:04 pm

Don’t give up on your silent and huge majority of readers Garth – we may not post comments often or at all, however respect your right of opinion and who doesn’t benefit from considering alternative points of view. Michael Campbell (Vancouver business analyst) also often talks about the hate and threatening feedback he gets, similar to yours. Tough to be a public personality these days, particularly when your facts and data don’t fit other folks opinions or twisted view of the world. Hang in there – your daily blog is something I and many others look forward to each day. With respect…..

#72 The greatest fool.ca on 03.29.16 at 7:06 pm

Oh..and please don’t quit the blog. I’ve learned so much reading and continue to read it every day. Thanks for your hard work. ….don’t make him quit Dorothy!

#73 nonplused on 03.29.16 at 7:07 pm

Garth I love you blog and have taken much of your advice over the years, so thanks for writing it and thanks for putting up with us morons in the comments section! Reading this blog is a daily for me I almost never miss it. And I comment often, about half the time seriously and the other half of the time just punting around and trying (with only rare success) to be funny. I certainly agree with your stance on racism, it really has no place in the modern world (if it ever did).

I have a lot of HAM (Hot Asian Moms) on the soccer team I coach and they and their kids are wonderful additions to our country.

Ok back to the housing market for a second, a thought I had reading today’s post is this: Isn’t foreign capital inflows supposed to be good for an economy? After all, whatever it is they are buying be it houses or products or even food, doesn’t that mean more money in the economy and more demand for goods and services?

So using YVR as an example, if a HAM buys a house in Vancouver at a ridiculously high price, isn’t that a windfall for the seller? The seller still needs a place to live, so maybe they purchase a newly constructed home and a new car with the proceeds. Doesn’t that employ everyone from electricians to car dealers? And now the electrician has money to go buy a new TV, keeping the people at Best Buy employed? I would think the trickle down is too long to describe further but even the barista at Starbucks probably benefits.

The real reason behind crazy YVR pricing probably has more to do with (interest rate of course but also) zoning practices by the city and the limited amount of land available for new housing around Vancouver. Here in Calgary we can go for miles further in any direction (except SW due to a reserve on the city limit) and this definitely puts an upper limit on what houses cost because high prices incentivize builders to get busy building. So if HAMs want to come to Calgary, the more the merrier we could sure use the jobs.

Another example of HAM influence (Hot Alberta Money) is my favorite neck of the woods, the Fernie – Invermere – Kimberly area of SE BC. This area is inundated (or was until the Nutley-Oil fiasco) with money from Alberta either purchasing vacation homes or visiting for vacation. The Fernie ski hill would be a shadow of it’s current self without the convoy of Albertans heading that way every weekend of the season. I know a guy who makes a living building log homes and cabins out there and almost all of his customers are from Alberta. The locals love to hate the Albertans but the fact is that the scenery and lake water starved Albertans who flood this area every summer are a major source of income and property taxes for this region.

So I say if HAMs want to buy our houses at ridiculously inflated prices, let’s sell to them, go build a new house, pocket the change and hopefully another HAM will come along and buy that house too. That’s how you do business, not by shutting someone with money out of the market. I mean can you imagine the Fernie ski resort banning Albertans? Never say no to a dollar.

Hmm this might have turned out to be one of my best recent comments if I don’t say so myself.

#74 Jay on 03.29.16 at 7:09 pm

Garth, I pretty much live for the daily sermon from the “church of Garth”. Shutting the doors would leave your devote followers without their ” daily bread”.

Amen bro….

#75 boonerator on 03.29.16 at 7:09 pm

I disabled comments on my Youtube channel because of the creeps who autopost “this video sucks”.

Similar for Garth.
I appreciate about 10-20% of the comments, the main feature of the blog is his educational role. For example, I did not know preferred ETF’s existed before reading this blog, thanks Garth.

I imagine making people sign in to an account in order to post has a high cost in administrative time and effort.
It would induce some accountability to posters and discourage the trolls.

So, if you have to, kill the comments.
My $0.02

#76 Bob on 03.29.16 at 7:09 pm

Garth,

Delegate. Get a blog dog you trust to moderate the comments….you keep the daily blog going and let some other interested party manage the sewers.

All famous people do that…..

#77 victory on 03.29.16 at 7:10 pm

Garth, you perform an important service in the current media environment. But look after yourself too! As you say, it’s all about balance…
Sincere thanks for keeping it going this long. I wonder how close things are to fulfilling godwin’s law? Or are we long past that prosaic threshold?

#78 Rob Ford Lying in Repose on 03.29.16 at 7:11 pm

First…..Jeez Louise, Dougie!! This box is so damn tight around me – why couldn’t you at least get me a double-wide!!?? Bumbaclot, mon.

I can’t wait to get out of this box and into heaven. I’ve run a fantastic city. I don’t want to toot my own horn here but I’m the best mayor this city has ever had and St. Peter is gonna be thrilled with my customer service excellence!

Garth, don’t give up buddy. I’ve always enjoyed reading your blog in my drunken stupors, and that’ll continue in the free bar upstairs :)

As for those bigots and pinkos who attack Orientals buying houses, I just don’t get it. Those people worked like dogs to get where they are, they just don’t get the respect they deserve!

For those blog dogs attacking Garth – well, this… reminds me of when I was watching with my brother when Saddam (Hussein) attacked Kuwait and (U.S.) President Bush said ‘I warn you, I warn you, I warn you, do not.’ Well folks, if you think American-style politics is nasty, you guys have just attacked Kuwait. You’re a bunch of maggots. Like the Tronna Star. Garth, ignore these downtown elites. These people are all two steps left of Joe Stalin.

As for a video of me and Garth naked together smoking a pipe on Pride weekend, I cannot comment on a video that I have never seen or does not exist.

#79 EarlySpring on 03.29.16 at 7:11 pm

Garth thank you so much for your service! You have personally influenced me and my recent fiancé in our day to day living, spending, planing, and investing.
I come from a background where money was always short, I will never forget the time when I was 15 years old and was asked by my father with tears in his eyes if he could borrow the $100 I had in my piggy bank( I don’t think it got repaid haha), I was happy to help our family out and never have treated money as the most important thing in my life. But that being said was the moment I decided I would do everything I could to bust out of living below the poverty line and ensure I was somewhat responsible with my money and would educate myself on personal finance and wealth building. Your blog here has been the most beneficial to me this far as I enjoy reading short blips like this versus long dry books haha.
Fast forward to today and I am closing in on my 29th birthday(she’s 26), recently engaged(will share an account because we exchange fluids) and we are living in a rented apartment, combined income of 230K, very little debt, rolling portfolios and increasing knowledge on life and finance daily!
We will buy our first house together in my hometown soon, it’s close to Saskatoon so we can maintain our current jobs and the house will cost less than 200K as its a smaller house, but all we need for the two of us right now.
So take for what it’s worth but from this small town prairie boy I thank you, and I will continue to read your blog every day as long as I am able. But all good things come to a end, you have done a great service to the people who call Canada home, we all hope you continue but nobody is getting younger and you need treat Dorthy, Bandit and yourself as #1. I can’t imagine the time this takes away from the other two just to benefit the fools. I support your decision to call it done, but God I hope not!!!!
Take care sir and I hope to read tomorrow!

#80 Scumop on 03.29.16 at 7:11 pm

Keep fighting the good fight, Garth. There are a lot of us who appreciate your insights and research.

Let the haters hate – some place else. Moderate as harsh as you want or think is necessary – your place, your rules. Prefer you not close the comments section as sometimes a gem or two shows up. And there are a few regulars worth a read even if some seem to be drooling alcohol on the keyboard as they type.

Monkey-on-back:
I blame you for pointing out how sensible etfs are. Hooked for life on those critters now.

Aside:
People who believe garbage cannot be convinced otherwise by facts alone. A debunking attack on their treasured beliefs, no matter how well researched and on target, only strengthens their beliefs. A defect of mind common in humans.

#81 MoneyDriven on 03.29.16 at 7:12 pm

Garth,
First of all thanks for the blog and please dont take my daily guilty pleasure of reading your blog away.

I AM an immigrant to Canada over 20 years ago. I loved living in Vancouver but Policies have lead Vancouver to unlivable city. Sure greed, fear and low mortgage rates have exaggerated the problem many folds but the source of issue is the policies.

20 years ago Vancouver was the only place I wanted to live but now I hate living here. My fiance and I make just over twice the average household income and can not live any where (rich or poor hood) close to our work place. You can call me a whinny millennial but 1.5 hours drive EACH way, everyday for 10 hours work shift for BOTH of us to work is simply not a family life I want. My work is limited to Downtown and there is no job for me outside of downtown niether.

Anyway I cant figure out why government is talking about tracking citizenship which creates even more hate.

I PERSONALLY DONT CARE WHAT IS ANYBODY’S RACE. BUT I DO CARE WHEN MOST HOODS ARE EMPTY SINCE VANCOUVER IS BEING TREATED AS SWISS BANK ACCOUNT. IT IS VERY SIMPLE FOR BANKS TO TRACK DOWN WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM. WHY NONE OF THE POLITICIAN TRIES TO REGULATE THE BANKS AND WHERE THE MONEY COMES FROM. IT SHOULD BE EASY TO STOP OR VERY LEAST LIMIT OR AT MINIMUM TRACK DOWN THESE FUNDS.

Even though you have some nasty comments here. I want to add the only reason that I am staying in Vancouver is because of Canadian. I traveled a bit and Canada is one of the only place is you can immigrate and not be an immigrant for rest of your life. Even though I am not sure how much longer I can drive 3 hours a day to get to moldy house.

Thanks and keep up the work

#82 Brazil ex-pat on 03.29.16 at 7:12 pm

#14 HellYeah on 03.29.16 at 6:16 pm
In my opinion, the bigots and racists shouldn’t live in our country’s biggest (most expensive) cities anyway. I assume they can’t appreciate the diversity and culture that comes with being a destination for everyone from immigrants to the First peoples. Love yr neighbour or yr going to karma hell.

Haters gonna hate.
Potatoes gonna potate.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Don’t worry. All the people that actually “make the money” to support the economy are planning to leave. We already have. If a desolate empty city of foreign owned real estate is what you and the Govt of BC/Canada want…..well you are getting your wish.

#83 YVR Dave on 03.29.16 at 7:12 pm

Garth,

If the cost of your continued posting is shutting down the comments section, that’s a more-than-fair price to pay. Although the comment section is often entertaining and sometimes educating, there are more and more comments I just skip over. These are almost always the ignorant/racist/bigoted/jealousy-ridden ones. Nobody would miss them. There are plenty of cesspools on the internet that these posters ought to ooze away to.

You have every right to set the tone; it’s your blog. I agree with FF: just delete the offensive posts without comment. Denied of a platform, the authors of such posts would quickly give up.

#84 Mike in the Okanagan on 03.29.16 at 7:15 pm

“In this country we suck and blow with finesse.”

This is why I keep coming back for the pearls of wisdom. :)

#85 EarlySpring on 03.29.16 at 7:15 pm

#8 Vundo
Yes I agree Garth, shut the comments down. Make it more enjoyable for yourself. You don’t learn anything from us anyways hahaha.

#86 Bitter Much? (former sockeye sam) on 03.29.16 at 7:16 pm

The Story of Mr. Chan.

Mr. Chan was a man we all got to know quite well from a Aqua fit class at a swimming pool on the west side of Vancouver. He was a 76 year old Cantonese speaking Chinese Canadian who had lived here for a long time running his little grocery store. We used to find it not only shocking but a little bit comical when asked, “Hows it going today Mr. Chan and Mr. Chan would all get fired up about all the Chinese moving into his neighborhood driving the prices up for his children and grand children. He would also go on about how money was Acquired in China and he didn’t think it was right that he had to work his ass off in his little grocery store and these new people got their money the shady way. Mr. Chan seemed to know all about them and he wasn’t happy about it either. Last year Mr. Chan had a heart attack in the deep end. He died doing what he enjoyed. R.I.P. Mr. Chan, a true pioneer.

#87 Bottoms_Up on 03.29.16 at 7:16 pm

Garth you can’t shut down the blog, I need it here 20 years from now to show it to my kids!!

#88 #1 Guelph Fan on 03.29.16 at 7:16 pm

Garth i have never posted but have followed you for five years. I truly value your comments and much of the discussion (not all). Please keep it up, you are helping thousands with your straight talk on all things financial!

#89 R. Chu Canadian in Los Angeles on 03.29.16 at 7:17 pm

I love your blog. I’m a Chinese immigrant who grew up in Canada and moved to Los Angeles in 2005 and witness the crash firsthand. With a bit of luck I have made a bit of money from the rubble.

I came across your blog when researching Canadian real estate in hopes to replicate my earlier luck. So far its a waiting game, but your blog makes the waiting so much more enjoyable. Please keep it up.

I am sure you reach many people with a certain mindset and who truly appreciate your blog. Although it really does raise the question why the victimized hate filled audience even read this blog…

#90 John Mc on 03.29.16 at 7:20 pm

Great article. I started reading your blog about 2 years ago. At the time I also read most of the comments. I stopped that about a year ago when I signed on with you as our financial advisor. You got me with your article called Finding Balance. Basically you need to trust someone.
I think a lot of people posting comments here need to still find that balance.

regards

John Mc

#91 Rexx Rock on 03.29.16 at 7:20 pm

The real problem is the stupid politicians created this mess.Its really sad their policies over the years have really destroyed the country just like T2 and T1 now.Can anyone tell me what one thing they have done right lately.Policies that create raceism, unemployment,poverty and death.

#92 Montellino on 03.29.16 at 7:20 pm

Why not ban comments altogether for 1 month. Keep writing, you always have great topics regardless of blog dog input.. this break gives everyone a chance to reflect on their inner asshole and if they come back and persist with bs then ban them..

There are more people that appreciate the daily dose of greater fool than there are douchers…

#93 understood by few on 03.29.16 at 7:22 pm

I have no idea how you have the energy to moderate every comment.

Personally, if it were me I’d switch over to Disqus (or similar), cross my fingers there are a bunch of non-commenting semi-intelligent readers who will down-vote garbage comments into oblivion then use a judicial finger on what remains (as the site owner you still have final control of what is posted). Threaded comments make it easier to deal with off topic or hateful threads. If it’s easy, keep it going, if not, ditch comments.

If people are desperate to comment on your articles they can always go to reddit. Some (most?) of your articles end up linked to in r/PersonalFinanceCanada.

#94 David on 03.29.16 at 7:24 pm

Why not require commentators to sign in with their Facebook profiles? You might not even need to bother moderating the comments anymore. And the worst deviants could be easily blocked. After our local newspaper website began doing this the quality of the paper’s comments section improved considerably.

#95 moses on 03.29.16 at 7:24 pm

Dont shut down Garth 99 percent are good people enjoying an interesting conversation. It never hurts to be reminded of the hate that still exists in the world. If only people were as good as dogs unfortunately that will never happen.People will always get ugly when it comes to money. Keep up the great work

#96 NotSoNewToETFs on 03.29.16 at 7:24 pm

Thanks for doing the good work Garth. I send links to your blog to my daughter for light bedtime reading now and then. You kicked my rear into investing in ETFs a year ago and I’ve had $8k in free money dumped into my account (dividends!). I’m the only sibling of 5 that doesn’t own a house. One sibling sold a few months ago in a negative equity situation. One lives almost 2 hours from her job. One lives in a small town with a single employer. I am footloose, carefree, love renting, love investing, and am personally satisfied with my life. All thanks to your blog.

Please tell Dorothy WE LOVE HER for allowing you to keep writing.

#97 Tickles on 03.29.16 at 7:28 pm

I’d like to add my previously silent voice to those that suggest the disabling of comments before shuttering the blog. In a Canada where real estate dominates the news, commercials during the news and the newspapers your voice has been invaluable in bringing balance to the discussion.

Too many of my millenial friends have saddled themselves with ridiculous mortgages with the aid of their parents’ largesse and find themselves stuck to a hunk of concrete rather than free to pursue opportunity and adventure. Where has our collective perspective gone and why do people no longer flinch at the prospect of a lifetime of debt?

Please continue to educate us all and please exclude the menagarie of DSM-5 worthy misfits who clutter the comments section with their pablum and their racist vitriol.

#98 Xquebecer on 03.29.16 at 7:28 pm

Garth, I get where you’re coming from. I enjoy your comments, I don’t always agree but that’s the essence of discussion. I gave up reading the comments awhile back. Too many bigots and uninformed pinheads from both left and right, not to mention whiners and blamers of every stripe.
Don’t give up, just whizz the ignos from the blog. They won’t be missed.

#99 learningfromyou on 03.29.16 at 7:29 pm

Thank Garth for your daily post.

Please keep your blog, it’s the only piece of news I’m willing to read every night.

Every year Canada accepts many immigrants saving a lot of them from their past realities, sometimes going too far implementing “le Accommodement raisonnable” to that level that let me question if we need to fight for “le Accommodement” of the born Canadians, if I invite you to live in my house it’s straightforward clear for me that you should follow my rules? It’s not that clear? Otherwise it’s simple, stay where you are or go somewhere else.

This is your blog, simply take out everything that doesn’t share your values, the one that does not like it will suck it up.

Between “le Accommodement raisonnable” and the blog I choose the latter.

#100 BC_Doc on 03.29.16 at 7:30 pm

No life without wife– do whatever you need to do to keep your better half happy.

#101 doghouse dweller on 03.29.16 at 7:30 pm

Certainly, you have noticed the worldwide epidemic of psychos and fanatics. Listen to the wife, “Vivre heureux c`est vivre cacher.”

#102 cto on 03.29.16 at 7:32 pm

Garth
I have a great solution for you to switch gears a bit, and stifle the new age bigots that this crazy real estate environment has created.
Why can’t you do a couple blogs about cottage country real estate? outside the urban environs of the city.

#103 hope & ruin on 03.29.16 at 7:34 pm

#76 Bob on 03.29.16 at 7:09 pm

Delegate. Get a blog dog you trust to moderate the comments….you keep the daily blog going and let some other interested party manage the sewers.
_______________________________________

100%, I would volunteer for this job lol.

#104 hope & ruin on 03.29.16 at 7:37 pm

#93 David on 03.29.16 at 7:24 pm
Why not require commentators to sign in with their Facebook profiles?
__________________________________________

I’m pretty sure Nemesis linked his to twitter. Not sure how though.

#105 espressobob on 03.29.16 at 7:38 pm

Dorothy should moderate this blog, not Garth. That would prove interesting.

#106 lustingforhome on 03.29.16 at 7:38 pm

Hey Garth,

Love your blog, do not shut it down. I think this is one of those few places that calls a spade……. a spade

Great work. Keep it up

#107 Es in Calgary on 03.29.16 at 7:38 pm

Your website, Garth, is an amazing Cdn resource – not selling anything except prudent financial advice and exceptionally current economic and political data – allowing so many of us information that some of us have we’ve learned through experience not to trust from anyone trying to sell us something. I love the comments section (there are some really informative posters) and would be sad to see it gone. When one listens to all the hatred, bitterness and vitriol in our world, one can’t be surprised to see it occasionally on this blog too. I pray that we won’t lose you over the next several interesting years ahead. You will be vindicated. Thank you to Dorothy for her patience and you for your wisdom and fortitude.

#108 BG on 03.29.16 at 7:39 pm

The web 2.0 is the trash of the humane brain.

And by that I don’t mean that it attracts the worst kind of people. No.
I rather mean that it pulls the worst part from every one of us.

It’s so easy to be rude and have no filter on the Internet. No consequences, so what the hell?

I’m happy I didn’t comment yesterday and wasn’t one to piss you off that particular time. No illusions though, I could have been an asshole too if I had commented.

Connecting is great. Disconnecting is vital.
Most of the time we do not need to know what is going on in the world, or what people think.

What I think now though, is that your blog helped me a lot and taught me about risk.

One of my first comments here was that I was looking at condos with my then 30k net worth.
You only replied “Yikes!”.

So thank you Garth for saving me.

#109 North Yorker on 03.29.16 at 7:39 pm

Finally a voice of reason! Dorothy!

#110 Whatever on 03.29.16 at 7:40 pm

Only you Garth can decide what to do with this blog. The educational aspects of your writings are terrific. BUT, when you are wrong, you must fess up. A fessing up column is in order. You can do it.

#111 Peppy Sue on 03.29.16 at 7:42 pm

I’m grateful for your post today, Garth. I never miss any of them. But lately I too have noticed the increase of careless, veiled, and sometimes blatant comments. Thanks for tightening up the moderation and for the excellent blog. Please don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater.

#112 jaybee on 03.29.16 at 7:43 pm

But what other hobby will you come up with to take it’s place? And what about the income you make ‘by accident”?

#113 JamesA on 03.29.16 at 7:45 pm

If you take a walk in the woods and turn over a rock, you see all the little ugly nasty things scurrying about. That’s what web comment sections are to society. They are almost universally horrible in the long run.

If you still enjoy doing it, keep writing them and just turn off the comments (and turn on the ad revenue with tasteful investments ads (you can choose the subset that get shown) and make a bit of coin). Or *show* the comments for free and charge money to *make* comments, a la ricochet.com, keep jacking the price till the dregs of society fade away.

You have done a lot of great work trying to teach people how to keep off the financial rocks of life. You should run to lead the Conservative party. I would vote for you, if your first promise was to build a trebuchet and toss Kevin oleary and brad lamb into Lake Ontario.

#114 Big English on 03.29.16 at 7:45 pm

Dear Garth,

Your blog has educated me with regards to investing and tax avoidance. It has provided me with great amusement based on your writing skill and wit. Please do not stop the blog.

People are afraid here in Vancouver and there fear is making them behave in an uncivilised manner.
The same individuals who attempt to make others feel inadequate for renting and providing for there families, are either swimming in debt or believe they’ve missed their chance to buy.

Only time will show them either the error of their ways or the risk they unintentionally avoided.

I wish Dorothy and you all the best.

#115 vic guy on 03.29.16 at 7:46 pm

If the sewer backs up and fills your house with shit to the ceiling… you have two options.
-Raise the roof.
-Get rid of the shit.

#116 E Richard on 03.29.16 at 7:47 pm

Well Garth at about seven years guess your blog is the longest one I have been reading daily. Was looking to have a place to call my own, I had been priced out of the the market. Did a three year tour in Alberta, came home and looking for another adventure. Better than struggling with two jobs to pay a mortgage, utlilites, and home maintenance. Thanks for making me realize better to have some fun in life than being a slave to a house.

#117 Robbie on 03.29.16 at 7:47 pm

Wonderful move, Garth. I stopped doing an occasional post a fair while ago because I was appalled at the low level of discourse…with some exceptions, of course. Enough ignorance, nastiness, abuse, diatribes, failure to listen, failure to read, failure to understand and mindless ranting! I’m looking forward to some reasoned discussions about all the important matters you have been bringing forth for so many years.

#118 Bank of Millennial on 03.29.16 at 7:47 pm

Garth – I appreciate the service you fulfill.

If you could somehow separate the posts you respond to at the top of the comments, it would make it easier for those of us who are trying to form a critical opinion and following along in the discussion… as opposed to sorting through the sewage.

Many thanks.

#119 Mr Happy on 03.29.16 at 7:47 pm

PLEASE DON’T QUIT!!!!!!

I, like MANY here, heed your words and advice.

Again, please continue your service. Remember the parable Jesus told, the shepherd would leave the 99 sheep to find the one lost sheep?

I am one of the lost that is slowly finding my way…

I need you Garth!!!!

#120 Steve on 03.29.16 at 7:48 pm

Garth, reading your blog is literally a daily ritual for me, going on 4 years. I greatly appreciate all you’ve written, although I suppose my wife wouldn’t be (haven’t yet bought our first place). If the idiot commenters are too much, why not just turn off comments? I’m sure you appreciate the thoughtful conversations, but still.

#121 the Jaguar on 03.29.16 at 7:48 pm

I have often wondered how you manage to stomach some of the crap that is posted here, Garth. There are other offenses as well.
A lot of multiple postings on the same day. Sorry, Mark, but you are an offender. Then there are the misogynist rants of others who can be identified by their initials (F.F.).
See the helpful reminders from Garth at the bottom of the post and note the reference to post comments “on the topic of the posting”.
Hang in there, Garth. You are a national treasure. Kick the creeps out, censor those that require that treatment, and carry on. It would be a dull world without your insights.

#122 mark on 03.29.16 at 7:49 pm

Larry Berman from bnn i think is a balanced rational host, who has preached in his opinion interest rates will stay historically low for decades and no MAJOR long term rising of rates, from the USA. Countries are like the average consumer there screwed if rates double or more and this is worked into the “system”, call it a scam, crooked, or whatever, food for thought.
I could care less either way but contrary to some thinking on this site, and could mean preferreds are screwed for a long time to come and may take decades to return there losses over the last several years.


Berman is wrong. Rates will remain historically low, but not at these levels. Preferreds have a bright prognosis. — Garth

#123 Linda on 03.29.16 at 7:50 pm

Always easier to blame someone else for your troubles, but not exactly the kind of behavior that gets or merits a whole lot of sympathy unless that ‘someone’ is actually doing what you claim they are & you have stand up in court proof of it.

As for deleting those who want to spew nastiness instead of engage in reasoned discourse, delete at will. Won’t miss the nasty stuff one bit.

#124 Rich on 03.29.16 at 7:53 pm

As a realtor I appreciate the time that you put in and the advice that you give. You advise people to use a professional realtor when they buy and sell real estate. You tell them to not put all of there investments in real estate. Totally agree with you. My team and I are different. We believe in financial planning while we help people buy and sell. Don’t stop what you are doing. You are a breath of fresh air and what you preach is sound advice. Signing off from Barrie.

#125 Alan from Edmonton on 03.29.16 at 7:53 pm

Hi Garth,

This is my first comment (and maybe my last), but I can see that you’re at the crossroads and thought that this might interest you.

In December 2010 I returned from Afghanistan (aged 25, girlfriend and no children) with $50,000 burning a hole in my pocket and immediately started thinking of all sorts of dumb purchasing decisions. I told my dad that I was thinking about buying a house, he replied with one sentence:

“Go read greaterfool.ca and get back to me”

And I did. Fast forward to today, my wife and I without too much effort have managed to put away over $360,000 – and it’s still growing. All we had to do was not buy stupid things, and keep adding to a balanced portfolio that we manage ourselves. Our friends and co workers stress and worry, constantly fighting debt and dealing with all the overpriced boat anchors they have chosen to weigh themselves down with. My wife and I are grateful every day to only have to deal with the stressors of marriage and an overactive one year old.

So thank you Garth, in a world seemingly designed to pilfer our pocketbooks at every turn you give some solid advice.

And yes, some of the comments that make it into the “Steerage section” of this boat of fools are truly disgusting, and I fear is a symptom of the direction in which this country is moving. A quick jaunt over to the CBC news comment section will show similar results.

I read every article religiously, and appreciate your efforts – but if you want to shut this down and move on with your life I understand. It must feel like shouting into the wind some times.

#126 nbe on 03.29.16 at 7:54 pm

Don’t let the losers get you down, Garth. They are brutal in their ignorance and hatred, and it can be really hard for me to ignore them at times. Just focus on all the people that really respect you and look forward to learning all the lessons you have to impart.

#127 joblo on 03.29.16 at 7:55 pm

“No higher principles involved. No ideals or values to fight for. Nothing noble or moral.”

The blog is just the opposite of this.

Block the assholes IPs

#128 bertvl on 03.29.16 at 7:56 pm

Hi Garth, I haven’t read all the comments so someone else may have already said this. I love reading your blog, but seriously, if you aren’t loving what you do, you should just take a step back. My suggestions would include maybe taking a two-week break and re-evaluating.

You also have a technical issue which in my view increases the pressure on you and lowers the quality of the comments. I suggest you change the WordPress settings to allow user account creation with full email-address validation. The current “open to all” zero-validation setup is definitely part of the problem. Only registered accounts should be able to comment.

You should be heavy-handed but consistent with moderation, and enforce scrupulously the rules (which should be “rules” not “helpful reminders”.

Finally, and very seriously, stop posting on the weekend! Five posts a week, Monday to Friday, and that’s it!

I would understand if you quit, but I hope you continue. Best of luck :)

#129 x-moose on 03.29.16 at 7:56 pm

Great topic. Unfortunately not entirely novel and already beaten to death.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6zkL91LzCMc
http://thelibertarianrepublic.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/111315-RickMcKee2-1024×678.jpg

#130 BlorgDorg on 03.29.16 at 7:57 pm

I read your blog dutifully every day, and love what you have to say. But I dare not tread into the comments — it’s not worth filtering through the bullshit. Can’t even imagine what you’ve had to moderate out.

As others are suggesting, shut down the comments. Save yourself the headache and instead enjoy your time with Dorothy and Bandit. Living well is the best revenge.

#131 lala on 03.29.16 at 8:00 pm

If you ban my ip ill delete myself, now on ill behave.

#132 wade on 03.29.16 at 8:02 pm

haters are gonna hate and potaters potat….i love how brave people get hiding behind there computers and spew…

#133 A box in the Sky on 03.29.16 at 8:02 pm

GT:

There is only one solution: You post your daily blog and just have the comments locked.

Sites like The Atlantic & Bloomberg do it for certain authors because their comments section just gets overrun with mouthbreathers.

#134 raisemyrent on 03.29.16 at 8:03 pm

Madness all around us. I live in Vancouver, so I hear it. My old co worker left coquitlam for Victoria (bought and sold etc the usual madness) because his wife couldn’t stand the Asians anymore. The Australian in the car also agreed. She’s from Eastern Europe and speaks little English. Which I pointed out (being an immigrant myself). Sigh…
I’ve been reading every post for about 2-3 years, but in the last few months, I’ve stopped reading the comments. Never really knew why but come to think of it, it’s gone from adding to the topic to generally wasting time reading garbage other people spout. Spurious facts. Isn’t that what Facebook is for?
Shame but troop on, Garth. Delete and block. Just like with ex girlfriends hehe
Also, you have to wake up Bandit? Floyd stalks us every morning and you get a paw or nose if you show any signs of life…

#135 South Okie on 03.29.16 at 8:03 pm

Install any filter you like. Keep this blog alive!

#136 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 8:04 pm

Perhaps Alen Watts was a time traveler. Came to future and flowed me around and took notes. At Senica on a Tuesday night.

Getting hammered. Listing to a combo of Pink Floyd, handsome family, and my man Johnny Cash on the buds.

Shit people worry about. Being a raving lush, loonatic and gambling alien so under rated by sociaty.

Can’t take it with you to the electric universe when ya buy the farm.

I live in an encredible world. In reality in short bursts then out tripping for long road trips.

How can I patten this felling. This life style.

No safe spaces here. It’s wonderful.

#137 Al on 03.29.16 at 8:05 pm

Hello Garth, I read your blog pretty regularly and certainly appreciate your time, effort, and insight. I don’t always follow your advice, but it certainly colours my decisions. I rarely read the comment section though, so it saddens me to hear that it can be so rude and petty. Please keep up your efforts for the silent majority.

Cheers, Al from Victoria (the land of newly wed and nearly dead)

#138 waiting on the westcoast on 03.29.16 at 8:06 pm

#91 Montellino on 03.29.16 at 7:20 pm
“Why not ban comments altogether for 1 month. Keep writing, you always have great topics regardless of blog dog input.. this break gives everyone a chance to reflect on their inner asshole and if they come back and persist with bs then ban them..”

With all the free time, Smokey and Mark will engineer a new credit default swap and make billions… ;-)

Someone mentioned earlier about letting one of the blog dogs to moderate. What if Smokey and Mark take turns… It would be interesting seeing which comments make it and which ones are deleted…. ;-)

Garth – in all seriousness, thanks for keepin’on, keepin’on… I have learned a lot and had a number of good laughs to boot.

Don’t mind the haters but please allow meet to beat on them when they post.

#139 Hirsute Hipster, head down, texting on 03.29.16 at 8:07 pm

Sorry, Garth, I must have missed those comments you’re referring to. Snapchat has been way too much fun to look away this week!

Please just repost all those comments so I can scan through them, k.

Thanks, bro!

#140 Ed on 03.29.16 at 8:08 pm

Maybe you could do like CNN & CBC and write about how Donald Trump is a bigot/racist/fascist and a real naughty guy.

Everybody loves those view points..succumb to consensus and embrace group thought…

#141 Silver on 03.29.16 at 8:09 pm

keep up the good fight Garth

the comments you recieved are one of the reasons i left vancouver. the dialog was impossable to escape in downtown vancouver’s entitled core several years ago.
it has gotten rather nasty as of late i see.
after all it couldn’t be their fault… they have a right to a home.

best Silver

#142 SI2K on 03.29.16 at 8:09 pm

A well known digital performance artist and friend of mine has said that hate mail is how you know you’ve done important work. I’m inclined to agree.

#143 David on 03.29.16 at 8:09 pm

Hi Garth
This is my first blog comment – ever.
Been reading your blog with pleasure for a long time.
Please don’t let the ignorant and selfish occupy your thoughts of this flock
You are providing us education and insight found no where else from my view
most appreciated and thanks!!!
Can i ask about if the US debt gets to the point of… where QE no longer controls… the US$… would the loon follow the same ride for inflation/deflation of the yank $ (how tied are we really if the US$ tanks)? (read a “death of money” J Rickards book just wondering your thoughts.

#144 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 8:18 pm

Click on my name lefties , look at my pic. Rat me out to my boss. Oh wait ya the Boston gig. Bull shit story of sorts. I made 14 mil from June to Jan. Why would I work.

Am I not handsome beast. 30 years of heavy smoking , 5 years of heavy drinking. Big macks for lunch every second day. Bacon and eggs everyday

When you give no shit is the day your free….
Most of you cowards will go to your Graves afraid.

God why me… why the gift of logic. There is a entire world lost do it rights out there. Must have been our conversations on the lake where I called you everything under the sun. Normally one lightning bolt would shut the bastard up. But you too god are addicted to my spirt , it’s to early to take me out…

You love me cause I’m not a mindless follower. Running the universe gets pretty boring.

Breath of freash air eh.. God.

#145 BOOM! on 03.29.16 at 8:21 pm

Garth,

You have been here…since before I came here, which was…. never mind, but quite awhile ago.

6 days a week, whether shattered ankle, or not.

Wonderful, actionable, FREE Advice, with no commercial agenda! I say ‘commercial’ because I believe it is your wish that all who read your advice, should they apply it, could benefit from it.

What, my friend, could be a higher calling?

You will decide when the time is appropriate to say “No more.”

I will say only, “Thank You” for all you have done, and continue to do for us, the readers here.

formerly, Retired Boomer WI

#146 espressobob on 03.29.16 at 8:22 pm

Society today is rife in ignorance. Change happens fast. Keeping up with this reality has emotional impacts.

Blaming other cultures for the competition they provide is a poor excuse for those that lag.

Try to keep up if you can.

Entitlement exited stage left. Bummer.

#147 Tim on 03.29.16 at 8:24 pm

Hi Garth, thanks so much for your energies into this blog!

There isn’t anywhere else where I can read sensible financial advise and news analysis written in such a fun and stylish way. There have been quite a number of laugh-out-loud moments — your description of the dead cat bounce a few weeks back still makes me smile.

I come here for Garth’s writing, not for comments. If I look at comments at all, I scan through them looking just for the ones that have Garth’s responses in italics.

Thanks again for years of almost daily posts, Garth. I do check the site most evenings to see what is new, and hope it works for you to continue.

#148 Dig Deep on 03.29.16 at 8:25 pm

You are a truly great Canadian doing noble work during truly troubling times. Thank you for fighting the good fight.

Illegitimi non carborundum.

#149 Mrs. Saves-a-lot on 03.29.16 at 8:26 pm

Thank you for your daily thoughts on the Canadian economy and real estate market. I, selfishly, hope you never stop writing.

Another commenter had, what I thought was, a good idea; require commenters to sign in through their Facebook accounts. By removing their anonymity, maybe people will think before they post.

#150 Silent Majority on 03.29.16 at 8:27 pm

Garth,

I haven’t commented on here before, but in light of your latest post I feel it’s due for all the help you’ve indirectly given me over the years.

It’s a shame that a small vocal group can cause such issues for dedicated readers of your blog. I sympathize with the frustration you must be feeling with all the negative comments. As a son of immigrants parents who came here in the late 70’s, you’re a lot more patient that I would have been.

That being said, I would like to show that your message is not falling on deaf ears.

Is this an anti-housing or real estate bashing blog? No.
Is this a investing instead of housing site? No.
Is this a USA market pumping site? No.
This site is about balance.

Balance in finances and balance in life and this has personally helped me a great deal. As someone who maintains balance in their life, I’m a lot happier for it. Unfortunately too many people seem happy to spend too much time trying to “prove” incorrect information that ultimately isn’t the message. Please ban/remove all these sham posters from the site and we’ll all be better off.

“Champagne for your real posters, …”

#151 Bitter Much? (former sockeye sam) on 03.29.16 at 8:28 pm

What is racist about the Chinese complaining about the Chinese. You have to watch the video to really understand what is going on in Vancouver. A lot of the pissed off people are Chinese. You can’t make this shit up. We have a true crisis. I’m also am so sick of hearing, “well you should move”.I think this is being racist towards Me.Why do I have to move? My kids go to school here and my wife and I work right in the city. You pick up all your shit and move!!!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=upTGzdlPUdA

#152 fiscally conservative lefty on 03.29.16 at 8:29 pm

Over the last six months or so, I’ve learned a lot from this blog. I’d been wary of how much real estate I’d been holding, and your writing was part of the push to liquidate and realize my gains while I still could. Putting your ideas into action has saved me a lot of financial grief and has made me feel much more secure.

We wouldn’t agree on a number of things (particularly politics, though I’m not a Trudeau fan either ha ha) but I’d have a beer with you any day.

I wouldn’t blame you if you shutter it (or nuke the comment section – moderating racist bs has to be draining) but just wanted to say thanks, regardless.

#153 John on 03.29.16 at 8:30 pm

Garth,
most of the comments are not adding value to the blog. As for the racist comments, simply delete. I think we all know Vancouver has been overrun by offshore speculation and money laundering. And this has nothing to do with racism–but calling it racism is a very effective way of shutting down the discussion isn’t it? By the way, since you started this blog have you ever advocating buying real estate in Vancouver? How much has real estate gone up since you started this blog?

#154 crowdedelevatorfartz on 03.29.16 at 8:32 pm

Well Garth.
It would be a shame if you shut the blog down but even Seinfeld went out on top.

As for the idiots and racist losers that seem to blame everyone BUT themselves for their financial problems.
Dont even give them the satisfaction of a “DELETED” notice.
Just nuke and pave.
No explanation. No comment. Nuke and pave.
Its much faster and much more satisfying knowing that they spent time typing their drivel and you nuked it in a nanosecond with barely a second thought.

Start with #21 Lisa Lisa.

#155 Erick on 03.29.16 at 8:33 pm

Hey Garth, don’t give up – that’s what they want !!!

In last resort, you may make the blog accessible through a verified email address – that would make it easier to ban those who don’t behave

#156 Addiction on 03.29.16 at 8:34 pm

Garth, you are addicted to this.
That’s what you like to do above everything else.
Turner Investments is just a “day job”, not a passion.
Once a journalist always a journalist.

#157 Tom from Mississauga on 03.29.16 at 8:37 pm

Shut comments down, at least for the summer. Or restrict the amount of text like Twitter. Also those that post multiple comments a day. Don’t tire yourself it with it. It does nobody any good. Good luck with your decision!

#158 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 8:38 pm

#128 Addiction on 03.29.16 at 8:34 pm
Garth, you are addicted to this.
That’s what you like to do above everything else.
Turner Investments is just a “day job”, not a passion.
Once a journalist always a journalist
….

That’s a given. But he’s never not been a journalist. Been a fan for a whIle . Lynda leather something not even close.

#159 Back to business on 03.29.16 at 8:39 pm

Yellen today. Dovish. Bloomberg: interest rate raise likely pushed to January 2017 in any meaningful manner.

That will start you up Garth.

#160 Freedom First on 03.29.16 at 8:42 pm

I had to post today.

Good on you Garth!

To everyone else: “help ever, hurt never”, as I try to do.

Also. I believe that the degree to which you love yourself is equal to the love you have to give to others.

And. I fall short in these things. But I keep trying.

Thanks Garth. You are an inspiration.

#161 ILoveCharts on 03.29.16 at 8:43 pm

#38 ed: how was that racist?

#162 alphonse on 03.29.16 at 8:44 pm

there is enough hatred in the world. great to see Garth limit it.

#163 Lea on 03.29.16 at 8:45 pm

Please keep the blog going! I have learned so much here.

Let’s get back to talking about interest rates. Here in Los Angeles, I just heard the dreaded word: flip.

Real estate is heating up again and I am hoping that a rising interest rates keep prices in check. There is a lot going economically and it would be a shame if people get distracted by flipping houses.

Torontonians and Vancouverians ignore real estate. Less demand will result in lower prices. Focus on building your business.

#164 Joe on 03.29.16 at 8:47 pm

Garth, I’ve been reading your blog for years…and will continue to do so as long as you publish. If I had to choose between Dorothy or these homeless (haha get it?) idiots on the Wet coast, I’d choose Dorothy.

Ciao
Joe

#165 waiting on the westcoast on 03.29.16 at 8:53 pm

#147 Bitter Much says…
“You can’t make this shit up. We have a true crisis. I’m also am so sick of hearing, “well you should move”.I think this is being racist towards Me.Why do I have to move? My kids go to school here and my wife and I work right in the city. You pick up all your shit and move!!!”

Quick question… For how long have you thought the universe revolves around you?

#166 Metaxa on 03.29.16 at 8:55 pm

Ever since the election the Wacked out lefties have invaded the comment section. Rabid rasists entitled victims.

It’s that much fun anymore.

They don’t even know when they are being spoken to….or about.

When you (vous, not tu) allow yourself to forget what true conservatism is all about, when you lose any shred of dignity or empathy towards yourself or others, when all you do is rattle around in the same echo chamber as those who speak and think as you do, you end up split into smaller and smaller tribes.

As those tribes become smaller they become more afraid of others, of outsiders, of everything.

They begin to speak in code and euphemisms. Make up deprecatory nick names for our Prime Minister for example. They refer to other citizens in derogatory manners, dependent upon place of residency for instance.

The only noise they hear or will listen to is that which bolsters their feelings so they don’t notice until too late that their tribe is now too small to be effective in any manner.

Must be tuff to live a life like that. Maybe someone should ask Stephan what its like to be totally marginalized. If any one can find him that is.

I felt there was a lightening up on the moderation given some of the thoughts and the manner they were expressed of late.
I now see the reasoning…

Make us post under our real names.

I have a pretty unique one, maybe 4 of us in all of Canada. I’d still post because I own my words, I don’t hide behind nothing. Plus I’m old, way old. I remember when Progressive Conservatism was an honourable thing to be a part of…

#167 lurker on 03.29.16 at 8:59 pm

As always thank you for the blog!

A few months ago I started skipping the comments section, and just enjoying the Garth created content. The comments have gotten worse, sorry you have to wade through that crap.

Thank you for not letting that dissuade you from continuing the great work.

#168 Alice on 03.29.16 at 9:01 pm

#71 Smoking Man on 03.28.16 at 10:14 pm

Going through hundreds of profiles of Ford haters on twitter. Many with reddiit links. Trying to figure out what makes them tick. I’m scientis after all.
—————
Nobody like geezer cars.

#169 VICTORIA TEA PARTY on 03.29.16 at 9:02 pm

LOVE MAY BE MANY A SPLENDID THING…BUT…

…greed is a many tacky and tattered thing:

To wit: Victoria real estate. In January friends sold their entirely modest home, located in a nice (expensive) part of town, for the considerable asking price.

The four sale sign was displayed out front for a mere 24 hours.

The other day the revenue property right next door went for the asking price, way up in the high six-figure bracket, following about four days sitting on the market.

For weeks I’ve hearing that the Chinese and rich refugees from Vancouver are bailing the Big Smoke to buy up whatever’s left over here, so burnt out they are with the nuttiness going on over yonder.

Meanwhile the Victoria rental market is fully zero in terms of the vacancy rate.

That is only partly true. If you are willing to layout whatever it takes to rent some place, then there is a place for you (at least 12-15 hundred a month minimum).

Fear always follows greed. Which means that when prices start to come unglued, at the market top, the floodgates of the fearful will ignite and all is lost until there’s “blood in the streets” by which time the market begins to re-balance.

So, St. Garth of “red sky in the morning…” many of those half-wit racists and other unfortunates who stuggle to shovel together a few incoherent sentences to vent their rage and frustrations are belwethers, canaries in the mine-shafts of our economic civilization, who are, in fact, providing a useful service.

They are advising the rest of us that all is not well in Canadian (Vancouver/Victoria) real estate. And if Victoria’s market is perking up as much as some of us are led to beleive, then Vancouver is a real estate Titanic which is about to discover its very own iceberg.

Couldn’t happen, at a better time, to such greedy people and their giant, mis-shapen egos.

Keep on keepin’ on, Sir Garth.

#170 Brian on 03.29.16 at 9:05 pm

Hi Garth,

Please don’t give up on the blog, it’s been a daily ritual for me for almost 4 years. Maybe it’s time to stop allowing anonymous comments.

#171 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 9:06 pm

Gartho been tweeting with Goldstein. Want to have a drink with him. Set it up.

#172 For those about to flop... on 03.29.16 at 9:09 pm

Just got a letter in the mail from one of the superannuation accounts I have in Oz.
Last 6 months to Dec 31st 1.5%

Return for the year 7% on the nose ,that made me laugh…

M41BC

#173 vulcan without ears on 03.29.16 at 9:09 pm

The solution, go weekly or in french.
Pourquoi pas?

#174 PG73 on 03.29.16 at 9:10 pm

Makes a lot of sense Garth – I used to enjoy scrolling through the comments but they have become tiresomely fixated as of late. Can’t imagine personally approving this garbage – or slogging through the drivel that qualifies for deletion. Ugggh.

I am hopeful you will find a way to keep things rolling – ever toyed with reddit-esque style comment voting? Perhaps wishful thinking but I suspect the vast silent majority would suppress the garbage….

Or screw it – a blog without comments is far better than no blog.

#175 broader mind on 03.29.16 at 9:10 pm

Garth, I love your blog and thoroughly enjoy reading the mostly comic and inappropriate comments.I’m even guilty of laying out a little kibble for the dogs to chew on.When the crazies come out in full force as witnessed lately there must be some kind of investment correlation (Hate-o-meter).Any insights?Real estate collapse? That many nutties must mean something.Maybe Trump victory and world annihilation.Bottom line, I respect and mostly agree with your thoughts.Hope you continue.

#176 CanMex on 03.29.16 at 9:11 pm

Suggestions – 1) Limit comments to 140 characters (enthusiasts love to pontificate). 2) Forbid the use of acronyms (bigots love to hide behind them). 3) Finish the weeding faster and sleep a little longer.

Unless you really enjoy encouraging the fringe-dwellers, of course.

#177 Randy Randerson on 03.29.16 at 9:11 pm

Keep the blog GT, just disable the comment section that has recently been taken hostage by racists, bigots and Wetcoasters (see how I’m generalising here?) Haters can start their own blogs and their own vitirol-filled groupies.

#178 DodgedBullet on 03.29.16 at 9:16 pm

Garth, you’ve changed my life for the better.

Thank you for the education.

DB.

#179 WalMark of Sadkatoon on 03.29.16 at 9:18 pm

poor ppl are always angry

especially when their insecurity of having no money is rubbed in their face in the form of unattainable real estate

sux to be poor

#180 WalMark of Sadkatoon on 03.29.16 at 9:21 pm

Gartho is using this site as an arm of the CSEC/Five Eyes to gather info on the miscreants in our society

http://m.huffpost.com/ca/entry/5419381

u herd it here first

#181 H on 03.29.16 at 9:21 pm

I would shut it down. This way you would spend less time sifting through comments that agree with you and deleting the ones that dont.

Truth but you will likely delete this anyway.

PS–how about Yellen today. So much for those rate hikes.

#182 YEG_guy on 03.29.16 at 9:24 pm

I agree with a lot of the posters, disable the comments. It’s the content of your commentary that I read daily.

I didn’t have a clue what a balanced portfolio, etfs or what a TFSA really was, until I found your site. The free knowledgeable advice you provide was/is enabling.

Thanks for your contribution to the interweb, Garth.

#183 Methusala on 03.29.16 at 9:25 pm

Garth,

It would be sad indeed if your sage advice stopped. I am old enough to remember when you ceased publishing your forum to pursue politics (for a second time) years ago and recall the sadness I felt then.

Hang in there sir. Many of us would be very grateful if you did…

#184 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 9:26 pm

#167 Alice on 03.29.16 at 9:01 pm
#71 Smoking Man on 03.28.16 at 10:14 pm

Going through hundreds of profiles of Ford haters on twitter. Many with reddiit links. Trying to figure out what makes them tick. I’m scientis after all.
—————
Nobody like geezer cars.
..
.

That’s because they’ve never ridden shot gun in a 69 chevel with holly carburetors. Slicks and 400 hundred house power and an forging stick and clutch.

Enjoy your smart car.

Last bitch I took for a ride in that beauty . The idot married me. Talk about risk. She bet well.

#185 smbs09 on 03.29.16 at 9:28 pm

I have a diversified portfolio instead of putting all my paycheck into a poorly built house partly because of your blog. I hope to keep reading your daily posts GT.

#186 acdel on 03.29.16 at 9:29 pm

That’s a great post but I disagree with posting real names. In today’s day and age anything one says will be used against them for the rest of there lives due everything being recorded on the Web.

You say you are an old guy; gone are the days where one could freely demonstrate on the street corner without the fear of being arrested, pepper sprayed,shot, beaten up just for expressing yourself; you see it everyday on the news.

Good honest whistle blowers have had their lives destroyed for telling the truth.

The last freedom of democracy (although IP’s can be tracked) are blogs like these. Whether one agree’s with the comments or not, you have a choice not to read them. Many time’s it is not due to hate but to frustrations of life, it is a way to vent! Do I agree with many of the comments, no, but I respect what they have to say. We have been so constricted in what we can say, write, or even think about in today’s world that it is just becoming a huge bubble ready to burst.

I respect very much what Garth has offered us over the years. Garth it’s clear by today’s blog you have hit the wall. Shut is down for awhile, take that vacation with your wife and the bionic dog, make that important decision on what is next; thanks again.

#187 gumboot princess on 03.29.16 at 9:29 pm

I’ve been reading your blog for about 7 years-ish. Found out about it after reading one of your books. Went to one of your seminars in Red Deer and drove from Calgary to hear you in person.

I always appreciate your wit and your advice. I also appreciate your ability to see the long view with your political background and financial wisdom.

In the long run, just make your own choice – whatever brings you contentment. And I wish you lots of it!

#188 45north on 03.29.16 at 9:29 pm

blogbitch: Illegitimi non carborundum!

that’s what I say: don’t let the bastards get you down

#189 acdel on 03.29.16 at 9:31 pm

#165 Metaxa

My recent post was directed to Metaxa.

#190 Fakeologist on 03.29.16 at 9:32 pm

Moderating is a pain, I agree. Start with registration, it goes a long way to slowing down the nonsense. I enjoy your stuff.

#191 Cham on 03.29.16 at 9:34 pm

Hi Garth, A long time blog dog but first time poster. I learned abc of money and investing from your blog. Your writing completely changed my personal finance. I treat your blog as a path to financial freedom and pray it everyday.
Keep writing. Just shut the comments instead. Besides why would you spend your valuable time to moderate useless comments?

#192 Nature on 03.29.16 at 9:36 pm

OH boy, I never felt the need to post but this is crazy.
Garth you’re offended that people have “bizarre” views on the Internet.
HAHAHAHA
You’re a grown man that plays on personality of confidence, a master of financials, and benevolent advisor….. And you get offended by some stupid comments and threaten to shutdown unless people tow the line?

#193 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 9:45 pm

True story .

My first date with Mrs smokey. I pulled up on front of the house. Momma said ” you going to open the door for her” I said . “Lady is your daughter a cripple , she’s got this” then I do a four hundred house power burn out.

Took twenty years before I got her folks to love me.

But they loved me to most in the end… rip Marry and Ramsey

I lover you guys always. But you knew that. Give my regards to God.

#194 bill on 03.29.16 at 9:45 pm

Hi Garth
dont let them grind you down!
you are doing the good work.
A , Me and the cats are in your corner!
soon you will be able to ride the bike….and if you already have then more frequently

#195 Two-thirds on 03.29.16 at 9:49 pm

Garth,

As a reader for the past 7 years, having profited handsomely by your daily (and free!) advice on real estate, investments, politics, and even the occasional dog blog, I agree with others who suggest closing down the comment section; whether temporarily or permanently.

Divisionism has gone un-virtually viral; rich vs. poor, young vs. old, right vs. left, us vs. them. Lamentable behaviours and words are now the norm in the online world. The end must be nigh.

You have done an admirable job of letting most have a voice here at your personal expense and for that we are thankful. You have done this country a great service as a public servant and Canadians at large too, since greater fool launched. We owe you much.

But if you must choose between sanity and this pathetic blog, the choice is clear. Having to moderate and don the hazmat suit everyday thanks to the arrivist whackos is not something anyone should endure – especially on one’s own damn blog!

So thanks for everything; loyal readers will continue flocking here everyday as long as the blog lives. We know it is your house and your rules, and we are all guests here. Whatever you decide, we are behind you.

And to the angry squatters: this may be a pathetic blog, but we are a civil bunch too; Garth pays for it all, so he gets to call the shots.

Don’t like it? Feel free to start your own blog, elsewhere!

#196 GT Problem Solver on 03.29.16 at 9:50 pm

GT, don’t shut GF down. We need some sane guidance from someone who doesn’t just repeat what the RE associations make up like the MSM.

Got a great solution for you. As you say, countries no longer have walls around them. So, instead of shutting down the comments section or worse yet the blog completely, just hire yourself a virtual assistant who lives somewhere in this big world where the cost of living is a lot lower than YVR and $5 per hour is good money.

Heck, you could probably even get a poor Vancouverite who is over their head in mortgage debt and needs some extra cash to do it cheap!

Sure, you’d need to spend an hour or two training them on filtering what is acceptable and what isn’t, but once done, you are golden! When in doubt, outsource!

#197 The Great Gazoo on 03.29.16 at 9:50 pm

“Expect more deletes. Abusers will have their IPs blocked from accessing the site. ”

That’s a good first step that would be beneficial to you, Dorothy and your sane, reasonable and loyal readers. If that doesn’t work, just disable the comments section as someone suggested. Wouldn’t bother me, since it takes too much time to wade through someone of the nonsense, so I generally don’t spend much time there.

This is a place of financial sanity for people like me and I assume many others. I was with family the other night and dared to suggest that Toronto real estate was overvalued and could soften up in the coming years. Lots of stares of total disbelieve. I ended up just shutting up, total waste of energy. The herd is moving forward and don’t get in their way or you will get trampled – for now.

Garth, this is a great site, stick with it. You provide a valuable public service – similar to what you did as an MP just in a different vehicle.

#198 Perry on 03.29.16 at 9:50 pm

I just discovered your blog 2 weeks ago and have been reading everyday since. Keep up the good work!

#199 "Disable the comments" on 03.29.16 at 9:51 pm

That would be like asking the actor to go on the stage without audience.

#200 Gregor Samsa on 03.29.16 at 9:52 pm

People sense something is wrong and they are looking for someone to blame. The easy outlet for them is to blame “foreign buyers.”

If these people knew the truth, they would blame the criminal central banks and meddling governments holding us hostage with artificially low interest rates and who are intentionally trying to keep the bubble inflated.

#201 Just say no on 03.29.16 at 9:52 pm

I love this blog and would love to read more of Garth’s great writing skills and I get to look up the meaning of new words all the time. The comments I now skim over after reading the “first” few and that’s more than enough…..maybe this blog could post the best top 10 comments? I gave up Facebook for this.

#202 Big Dipper on 03.29.16 at 9:54 pm

#12 Old stock Canadian on 03.29.16 at 6:15 pm

Josh Gordon is assistant professor and Anjum Mutakabbir is a master’s student at Simon Fraser University’s School of Public Policy

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/rob-commentary/data-on-canadas-housing-market-is-fine-but-we-need-action-now/article29407997/

“Insane idea. Prohibitively costly to manage, plus demonstrably unfair as it links income and property value. Just what you’d expect from a masters student. — Garth”

———————————————–

Misrepresentation – the Senior Author is an Assistant Professor.

It strikes me that you have very low tolerance for persons and ideas not corresponding to yours. The G&M article identifies facts and proposes a diagnostic solution. No implied racism.

Meanwhile hateful venom attacks on lefties, pinkos, commies and T2 lovers are freely posted. Just read comments above. Do you see any problem with your role in that?

Threatening to quit sure gets a lot of ego stroking plea’s, doesn’t it.

#203 respect on 03.29.16 at 9:55 pm

While I disagree with your take on politics, I appreciate, follow and champion your financial advice.

Thank you for the charity.

Take comfort in the knowledge that the narrow-minded bigots are miserable, miserable, miserable.

#204 Clearwater79 on 03.29.16 at 9:55 pm

Garth,

Maybe try changing the conversation. I get the sense your blogs have been catering to the posters comments a bit too much.

Stopping your blog is not an acceptable option, I already cancelled cable, if you stop blogging I would cancel my internet too. Bad for the economy.

I suggest blocking any ip you dont like, dont think too hard about it, just do it.

On another note, business insolvencies are flooding into into the banks over the last month in calgary. Will get worse before it gets better in the ‘GUSTY TURNIP’ tm.

M37AB/BC

#205 McLatch on 03.29.16 at 9:56 pm

Garth let me start by saying that we all care about you and appreciate you for all you try to do.
From your obsessive concern for our financial well being though you have formed an unhealthy addiction. People who struggle with addiction are often in denial about their situation and unwilling to seek treatment. They may not recognize the negative effects their behavior has on themselves and others when it comes to addiction the person with the problem often struggles to see it and acknowledge it.

It’s time to let go of this repetitive cycle of daily posts. This cathartic experiment which I am sure takes it’s toll not just on you but those closest you as well. As you chase the high of a new post think of Dorothy, think of Bandit and lastly all the Amazons their hurt feelings of neglect as you pound out another financial life raft of hope for the uneducated masses stuck on a one asset strategy! The years spent trying to drive home the message of diversification. Oh the rush you must have felt once and yet now you can never quite achieve mired down in rants, racism and greed. Know that what you have done is much more than most but now is the time to let go.

I don’t suggest cold turkey the withdrawal could be dangerous, not just for you! But perhaps start to roll back your intake of output to a few times a week instead of daily, maybe limit the comments down to a specified time period rather than 24hrs. I too once read every article every line, comment and word. Eagerly waited daily for the fix of a fresh new post checking the comments for what came next. Now I limit my intake. It’s not easy but I must for it becomes all consuming.

Good luck kind sir and remember what you have done is much more than most for which I can never repay you, but that never was the point was it?

All the best
McLatch

#206 Pacman on 03.29.16 at 9:56 pm

Stepped away from my laptop to catch the news on TV. Heard a scream 5 mins later from my 10 year old “Oh NOOOO! DAD, he is going to shut it down”. She comes every day for the pictures. Guess she reads a bit too.

Thank you for the blog. Please add a “Donate” button. Whether you continue, or quit. We would like to show our appreciation. As I am sure would many of the others who read it. Fond regards!

#207 Bytor the Snow Dog on 03.29.16 at 10:01 pm

No way I’ll suck up to you…. to Dorothy, hell ya!

BUT….I agree with Acdel at 185 above. To me it’s all words on a page. People need thicker skin.

In my mind you’ve thrown out quite a few trial balloons in recent months. If you want to close the blog, just do it. I’m happy for ya and I hope the store works out great for you and your wife.

If you want to keep the blog open it needs to remain the same- full anonymous comments. If you need a loyal Dog to moderate, Bytor’s here for ya!

#208 Chris B on 03.29.16 at 10:03 pm

Please keep writing, Garth. I enjoy reading your columns, and I have learned a great deal from you over the years.

Thank you!

#209 Nemesis on 03.29.16 at 10:04 pm

“I’ve written 2,283 articles and moderated 412,039 comments.” – HonGT

#You’veEarnedYourVacation…

https://youtu.be/MX145Tu4MHY

#TimeIsOfTheEssence

#210 Scully on 03.29.16 at 10:08 pm

Garth, I think you are one of the most sane and intelligent people I know…and those two don’t always go together. ;) I read your blog and see your wise advice and observations play out in real life every day I go to work so it can be very frustrating to read some of the ignorant comments on here. I try not to because it can be depressing and life is too short. Please don’t shut down your blog. I do think that society is falling prey to a narcissistic mindset which, sadly, is getting harder to
escape. And just remember if they ever discover an anal polyp at one of my colonoscopies I will gladly name it after one of the racist, ignorant assholes that comment on here.

#211 common sense on 03.29.16 at 10:13 pm

Summer is soon here…take it off, enjoy the bike and post when you feel like it.

You can only give so much.

Your reasonable readers will check in often to see if a post is here and you may just lose the negativity…

Enjoy.

#212 Bitter Much? (former sockeye sam) on 03.29.16 at 10:13 pm

#164 waiting on the west coast
It’s not about me. It’s about my kids and their kids. it’s about my nieces and nephews. Watch the video and get educated. Maybe you’ll start understanding the crisis. Like #152 john writes.
“I think we all know Vancouver has been overrun by offshore speculation and money laundering”.
This is the part I love.
“But calling it RACISM is a very effective way of shutting down the discussion”.
Bravo!!!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=upTGzdlPUdA

#213 TurnerNation on 03.29.16 at 10:16 pm

Real traders know only price and volume matter.

Pathetic Canadians should be happy someone anyone is willing to pay 1 mill for their sht Long Branch bung.

#214 just a dude on 03.29.16 at 10:19 pm

Here, here! Garth, you’ve got my vote for keeping the assholes at bay. I’ve appreciated your many posts over the years and would hate to see you go. If these dicks can’t be respectful of you and of their fellow Canadians, recent immigrants or otherwise, then they can go to hell.

#215 For those about to flop... on 03.29.16 at 10:19 pm

Regarding posting anonymously,we have had that discussion before.
I cant talk on behalf on anyone else with a handle but I do it to protect myself a bit.
At various times of the year I talk about some of the bigger /high end builds going on in Vancouver and I would not talk about them without a bit of protection.

Also I have started showing photos of various houses slated for demolition and would prefer not to get rock through the window.

My main point is off blog,Garth and I occasionally communicate and the first time he said ” Should I call you Flop?” and I responded by telling him my real full name and my wife’s as a show of respect,after all I know his name , so I thought it was only fair.

Just because some of us have a handle,does not mean we post anonymously and I only post as For those about to flop…

M41BC

#216 Dave on 03.29.16 at 10:20 pm

Reach for the missus in the morning, not the iPad! Much easier to do if you just disable the ability for anyone to comment.

Thanks for the blog, it’s one of the few on my daily reading list.

– A Thankful Immigrant

#217 ClashFan on 03.29.16 at 10:21 pm

Hi Garth,

Thank you for doing this.
I can appreciate your frustration.
Idiocracy wasn’t supposed to be a roadmap to the future.

There’s a lot of frustration out there.

I’ve been reading your blog for a few years. I thought Canadian housing would pop after ’08. The longer this goes on the worse it’s going to be.

You have a degree of confidence in the future and the US market that I don’t share.

What happens when the whole world is like Japan ?

I’m a small business owner in southern Ontario. I don’t know what to do. Hydro rates are climbing. The provincial and municipal government’s don’t seem to understand that if I can’t make a profit I’m not going to run a business. And yet they keep handing out raises to the civil servants, teachers, cops and firefighters.

I haven’t had a raise in 16 years.
I earn about half what a teacher does.

Does a teacher have to keep $750,000 of inventory to get paid ?
Does a teacher’s customers go somewhere else if they’re not happy ?

The many taxes my business pays far exceed what I make running this business. And the tax collectors have no risk and they keep adding regulations and red tape to justify their existence.

The pendulum has swung to far to the left and it will change direction. Let’s hope the backlash isn’t to extreme.

#218 bsallergy on 03.29.16 at 10:23 pm

Garth the simple fact that you aren’t selling anything or advertising me to death tells me that you are trying to help.

thanks

#219 Steve on 03.29.16 at 10:24 pm

Keep the blog going please, close the comment section if it makes your wife happier, but please dont stop the blog.

#220 jane 24 on 03.29.16 at 10:24 pm

Garth may I suggest that you take a blog holiday and then when you return blog very second day. Eight years of this is indeed too much for anyone and must frankly be getting boring. At your advanced age the centre of your life should indeed be Dorothy and not this blog. I support your wife on this. Go somewhere nice.

Also pay another person to moderate for you. Get out of this part of the business. Too time consuming. Tell Dot, no iPads in the bedroom.

Re racist comments this is what happens when ordinary people feel and that is a key word versus know, that they are shut out of their own neighbourhoods. They don’t see a route to enjoy the life that their parents and grandparents had. The reaction is anger. The result is an expensive but empty city with shutting stores and empty schools.

The only answer is either massive building of starter subsidised homes or tax changes at the federal and provincial level to ensure that housing speculation and holding empty homes doesn’t pay. Here in Britain they have just changed land transfer tax so that if you own another home you pay far more if you buy a second. This is already slowing the market. Govt needs to act with tax changes but doesn’t as these housing problems don’t impact on the multi-millionaire politicians who run this world. Just us.

I have nieces and nephews in Canada that despair of every owning their own home and this does not make for a stable and happy life. It makes for anger and racism. This is the second largest country in the world too where there is no actual shortage of land either.

Boil must be lanced as the first world is getting ugly. Garth your blog has highlighted a crucial and growing civic problem so well done.

#221 John in Mtl on 03.29.16 at 10:27 pm

Well, Monsieur Turner, a while back, you did warn us this day was coming. Today you fire another warning shot.

I find you almost super-human to moderate all the comments and at almost all hours of the day. Seldom a quiet evening at home I suppose – always close to the computer because… gotta tend to the blog & comments. 6 days out of 7, that’s a lot of time and I can understand your better half might grow tired of not being able to spend more time with you. I also understand your growing exasperation with some of the disrespect here at times.

As many have suggested, shutting down the comment section would be somewhat sad but it might be a worthy compromise to consider. I enjoy the comments (most of the time) and enjoy your insights and writings even more.

It would truly be our loss if you hung your hat one last time and flipped the on/off switch. We are guests in your digital hangout space, and if the party’s over one day, c’est la vie.

#222 Scalgary on 03.29.16 at 10:29 pm

Garth,

You are changing lives of so many like me! I am confidently self managing my finances mainly because of this blog!

Please don’t stop educating us for sake of those useless personalities.

I am for getting rid of comments section.

Thanks again for your great service!

#223 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 10:32 pm

DELETED

#224 Swan song on 03.29.16 at 10:33 pm

Go with the flow.

#225 GTA guy on 03.29.16 at 10:33 pm

Hey Gartholomew,

Why not just make people post non-anonymously? It is exceedingly rare that sites allow fully anonymous comments without even a registration required. Ask your web guy – even if you made people log in with Facebook or Disqus or something similar, that’s enough to cut out the lion’s share of the nasty stuff. Sure the few will still find a way around it, but removing the thin veil of Internet anonymity will very quickly show these hateful bigots for the cowards they are, and keep most of them quiet or at least more respectful. The comments used to be fun, now it is just meh. These days I just search for “garth” and read the ones you’ve actually responded to and ignore most of the rest. Keep up the blog game – I may only agree with half of what you write, but that’s just because I have independent thought, and I also appreciate an opposing view. Even polar views can be of value if they’re used to balance their opposites. Don’t like the Liberals? Just put the dippers and cons in a blender and have a delicious centrist smoothie. Sometimes Garth you’re a lib, and other times you’re an ingredient in the blue and orange cocktail, but you’re always worth the time to listen to. Thanks.

#226 sean on 03.29.16 at 10:36 pm

I’ve been a daily reader for ~2 years, and a very occasional poster. Your blog has motivated me to move my investments out of the high-priced “walled garden” that the banks steer people towards, and into low cost ETFs using a discount broker. Your daily missive is much appreciated and will be greatly missed if it disappears, but on the other hand your life balance must be paramount.

If you do close up shop, would you consider archiving the content? My investment notes have quite a few instances of “see Garth’s blog YYYY/MM/DD” :-)

I do read through the comments section and value the input of a few posters, but I agree that recently the signal to noise ratio has decreased. If the price of keeping the blog available is elimination of comments, then so be it.

M48ON

#227 Dandelionfluff on 03.29.16 at 10:36 pm

I’m another in the long list of readers who enjoys this blog but never posts a comment. Probably for the same reason, we don’t feel we actually have something worthwhile to contribute and we feel that if we’re going to comment we should.

I envision this blog as a bridge, offering people one fairly easy to follow way to financial security through diversity and balance with practical suggestions on how to do so.

Some commenters are crossing the bridge, following the advise; some are on the bridge, suggesting alternatives; other are horking loogies off the bridge, but still kind of contributing or at least entertaining the rest of us.

Underneath the bridge are a hoard of commenters who include trolls; people muttering incomprehensibly to themselves; angry children who just don’t get it, declaring ‘BUT I WANNA HOUSE’ and ‘I WANNA HOUSE HERE’ before holding their breath, turning purple and passing out; and other sundry characters pushing for space.

I rarely read all, or sometimes any, of the comments here, though I appreciate some of the more helpful ones that have appeared from time to time. This blog has inspired me to get rid of all consumer debt (which I finally did last year) and has shown me that there is a way to financial freedom that doesn’t involve winning a lottery. My investment journey has just begun but I’m sure will be most entertaining.

It seems some of the haters just don’t get it. Some of the other tasteless posts seem to include people attempting to emulate your clever and barbed writing style.

Thank you, Garth, for your sensible advise. It has helped me immensely and I look forward to reading your blog for as long as you see fit to grace us with your prose.

(Really though, how could you close down the blog, would you really want to turn personas like dear Smoking Man out on the street or worse, loose on the rest of the internet…)

#228 TRUMP TO GARTH on 03.29.16 at 10:39 pm

You won’t get ahead by shutting it down.

And surely not because of a bunch of COWARDS hiding behind a keyboard.

YOU FIGHT BACK …… Give them a run for their level of intelligence. I promise it won’t take you much effort.

#229 not 1st on 03.29.16 at 10:39 pm

Garth, I dont know whats going on in Vancouver and Toronto, obviously nothing good.

However, I do vehemently disagree with you about the state of the US economy.

#230 WUL on 03.29.16 at 10:39 pm

Garth:

I expect you know where I stand on your body of work and the debt that we owe you and will never be repaid.

Perhaps a simple path for you to follow to serenity is to only allow comments from Calgary, Ft. Mac and Wisconsin.

Luv ya,

WUL

#231 R. McLean on 03.29.16 at 10:40 pm

Hi Garth—I’m a first time poster but a long time reader. It takes a great deal of writing talent and persistence to keep a blog like this interesting and current. Thanks for your hard work–much appreciated!
On another note–there is an increasing belief by some people in our country that they have the right to be nasty or obnoxious whenever they wish. I am in favour of what poster #153 says–we don’t need the aggressive and butt nugget comments that Lisa Lisa #21 drivels out so easily!

#232 Paul from Ft. Wayne, IN on 03.29.16 at 10:41 pm

I enjoy reading your blog. I worry that so many of the homeowners in Canada will owe more than their house is worth when the values drop. Are mortgages in Canada non-recourse loans?

#233 Eco Capitalist on 03.29.16 at 10:42 pm

First, thank you for all the free knowledge. I’ve learned a lot from lurking here the past few years.

Second, if blog fatigue is setting in, how about scaling back? I think most would prefer a weekly blog over no blog.

Cheers!

#234 bricklayer on 03.29.16 at 10:44 pm

well said Garth. it’s easy to post anything under a handle on the net. time to take out the garbage and while you are at it, please take the ‘firsters’ out too. what waste of space and time. sheeeeesh.

#235 SR on 03.29.16 at 10:47 pm

Long time reader and first time I’ve ever screen shot one of your comments.

“They’re angry. That becomes hate. And it’s a short trip then to prejudice, bigotry and racism – when hate’s focus grows wider and impersonal.”

We need more of this…

#236 Big Dipper on 03.29.16 at 10:51 pm

Actually Garth, you should hang in, but only because of the occasional appearance of Emma Faun, that underappreciated, overworked Intern and miserably abused slave of yours.

I think I have a crush on her. Could you mention that to her tomorrow morning? Tell her I’m more like a Bernie Sanders Dipper….

#237 Rebecca on 03.29.16 at 10:53 pm

Thank you for persisting in your daily blog, Garth. You provide great (and entertaining!) perspective on finances and where Canada is going with this real estate fetish.

It’s easy to get caught up in the HAM hype here in Vancouver, but regardless of one’s position on what the heck is wrong with Vancouver’s real estate market, racism and xenophobia are as un-Canadian as it gets. I hope that if you get sick of moderating, you’ll consider shutting down the comments section while continuing to blog.

#238 SR on 03.29.16 at 10:53 pm

Aaaaccckkk!!!! Re-reading that… “More of this” MEANT more of these enlightened thoughts and ideas from you Garth (and everyone)!

Now see how context in writing a blog is tough!

#239 Protea on 03.29.16 at 10:54 pm

You know Garth I have often when reading your blog when you were going to reach you tolerance level with some of the crap some idiots post.

Its human weakness that a big percentage of the population are morons. It would be a real shame if you were one day to shut down the blog because of the level of disrespect and intolerance to fellow human beings.. I for one have learnt so much from yourself and the thoughtful comments of the normal postings one reads. I have no objection to your deletions and the fact that you need to edit the comments re: racism etc.censorship can be necesary at times. Never missyour posts keep up the good work

#240 BK on 03.29.16 at 10:56 pm

Garth, please continue with your blog. It’s a part of my daily routine.

I personally have not seen anything that racist in the comment section. I can’t speak for your deleted posts…

My asian friends, who also read your blog think nothing of the “racist” comments other than it encourages discussion. Discussion is good!

It’s just words on a computer screen. People need to stop being so sensitive.

STICKS AND STONES

#241 Victor on 03.29.16 at 10:57 pm

Love your site. Lots of useful financial advice. If no more new content, please, keep the site with what it has now. It looks clear now, but it took a while for me to get the self directed tfsa account where 40K invested in a mix of REIT and etf can return 2500 a year. To get same money from GIC with a rate 1% and after paying income tax I have to invest about 500K.

#242 Wicked as it seems on 03.29.16 at 10:57 pm

Reading this blog for 7 years, post rarely but when I do it is with thanks and regards for information gathered…I travel a lot nowadays, but where ever I am I’m reading you at odd hours, in a street side cafe, looking at a jungle, but your always there and your my daily ritual, my reason to share Canadian small talk with locals….find a way to loose the haters and stick with it, has to be easier than standing in a hall in front of 500 people!

#243 IHCTD9 on 03.29.16 at 10:59 pm

My hat is off to Garth whose commitment to free speech in the comments section is admirable given some of the crap. But there are good dogs down here as well, something for just about everyone.

For those with HAM angst: try to worry about your own condition, you can’t control others, you can’t control the future, forget about government helping anything.

Things have a way of working out just fine, and your attitude is a big part of it. Change is going to happen, and you’ll need to find a way to make peace with it. Life will be tough for those who can’t peaceably adapt, that’s all there is to it.

Getting your blood pressure up over things you haven’t a hope in hell of ever changing is worse than smoking a pack a day. Doesn’t matter if you disagree with what’s going on, you’re sticking a knife in your chest. Find a way to see things in a palatable perspective, anger and resentment don’t do anything good for anyone.

As much as my wife would approve of a little more hubby time, I hope Garth is back again tomorrow :).

#244 BK on 03.29.16 at 11:04 pm

@ #233 bricklayer

Were you never a ‘firster’? This blog dealt with you now you must deal with others.

Any ‘firsters’ that follow this blog probably have a good head on there shoulders and are here to learn.

They are not a waste of time and you WILL rely on them sometime in your lifetime…

#245 Love my Kia on 03.29.16 at 11:07 pm

Today is one of the reasons I realize why I like reading your blog.

I am a self professed leftie with a social conscience and at times why I wonder why I bother reading posts from righties who are all about ‘the I got mine and screw everyone else’ attitudes.

I get angry when I see the social inequality spill over into hatred and find myself also posting out of anger on blatant racism and bigotry.

Call me a commie, Bernie Sanders’ lovin tree hugger – its a compliment to be on the right side of history.

You nailed it Garth, its just stuff.

Why Garth aren’t you a leftie?????? Its just stuff.

#246 Min In Mission on 03.29.16 at 11:07 pm

Regardless of the fact that I am one of the people that have the majority of my assets in one particular spot, that I will not specify, I enjoy reading the main post of the blog.

The comments I merely scan through, if that, mostly looking to see if the “Head Dog” has answered any.

Even though I am, situationally(if that is a word), unable to take advantage of the free advice, I still read it all and do monitor to see how accurate it is.

Besides, I am truly envious of the “way with words” that Garth has. Plus, the sense of humour is sufficiently skewed, and I like that.

#247 Sam on 03.29.16 at 11:10 pm

Garth,
I always wondered how you found the time and inclination to keep this blog running. I want you to know we are grateful. Take some Rae days but please come back. I have told so many about your site and have been able to help some by repeating what i learn from you and your readers.
If you choose to go,,, well then I thank you and your wife for all the time and effort you have afforded us.
signed – I have sooo much to learn

#248 Brian on 03.29.16 at 11:12 pm

Garth you need to take your share of the blame here by choosing to fan the flames on the topic of HAM. Nobody has the hard data to back up their opinion, even you. Yet you continue to belittle posters who suggest HAM is ruining this market by suggesting they are racist xenophobes, even when they post in a respectful, informed, direct manner. You get what you give. And in my opinion you can go overboard sometimes. The truth will surface eventually and well see who was right. Thanks for all you do.

#249 SunShowers on 03.29.16 at 11:13 pm

The only HAM worth talking about was served for dinner on Sunday.

Do what you gotta do Garth.

#250 jay on 03.29.16 at 11:13 pm

Garth,are you saying that all of these people posting from Vancouver are lying.

#251 Brian on 03.29.16 at 11:16 pm

I don’t hate anybody, but a government should put the needs of its own citizens ahead of non citizens. Nothing to do with race, just non Canadians taking advantage of the country my tax dollars support. The race and hate card is played way to quickly

#252 Anthony on 03.29.16 at 11:17 pm

Love the blog, but don’t post or even read the comments very much…

I’ve applied your principles to my own personal finance.

I’ve quoted you in discussions and recommended many others to read your blog.

I look forward to reading it every day. Thanks so much for sharing the knowledge and please don’t let vocal bigots force you to end the site.

For every vocal bigot in the comments, there are many more of us who just come to read the post!

#253 Steve French on 03.29.16 at 11:17 pm

Steve French here.

Long time pal of the Smoking Man.

I’ve been on voluntary suspension from commenting on the GF blog since GT told me off for saying that he didn’t care a hoot about inequality.

Whatever.

The point is:

Haters gonna hate!

And a Smokey’s gonna rant.

There’s little that can be done. Except to ban the haters.

Smokey- as you know i am a devoted Dudeist Priest.

Just to say I still come here every day.. but I lurk now.

.. Trying to stay on Sir Garth’s good side.

#254 NoOneOfConsequence on 03.29.16 at 11:17 pm

Garth, thank you for all your efforts and your continued perseverance in writing this blog. I really appreciate what you do. It’s quite incredible actually.
I was one of those people that you were targeting: over invested in a single asset, house poor all the time, living pay check to pay check, never saving a dime. I didn’t have two nickels to rub together. Every time I got ahead…the roof would leak, the hot water heater blew up, the deck needed replacing, etc, etc. My house in Van was costing us more than what I made. I was slowly sliding into financial oblivion.

Finally sold the beater house and rented a beautiful home for less $$ monthly. Got completely out of debt. Opened TFSA brokerage accounts. Invested the little i had left in a mixture of ETFs and preferreds.
It’s almost surreal the change: I have money to enjoy a few luxuries, I am committed to my balanced portfolio and my balanced life!! I am teaching my children what I have learned from you.
It’s amazing how fast investments grow when you are committed and disciplined. For the first time in my life I am not nervous or worried about having enough money.
Compared to most…the money I have invested would seem minuscule…but compared to slowly going in the hole for 10 years…it’s amazing!!

You do good work here. I never would have found the way without your blog.

On behalf of me and my family, thank you.

#255 Ronaldo on 03.29.16 at 11:19 pm

Have been reading your blog since 08 Garth. Never missed a one. Funny as I was driving up to the Okanagan from the coast today I was actually thinking about the very thing you posted and wondered how on earth you could possibly have done what you have without some fallout from your spouse. I bet that most men on this blog actually have to keep the fact of our blogging from our wives. I probably spend 2 hours a day on this site and I can say that lately the amount of garbage that emanates from some of these bloggers leaves much to be desired. It has gotten to the point that I suspect that many like myself feel like packing it in. This blog certainly attracts some dandies to say the least. I never thought our country was as racist as this blog would indicate. I have personally witnessed this as a young child towards our natives. It was very saddening. Having moved from the prairies to BC, I could not believe the attitudes towards the first nations people. Now it is towards the Chinese. I have several Chinese relatives, 2nd, 3rd and 4th generation. I’ve worked alongside many over the years and went to school with some. We could learn something from all of them. This blog was a lot of fun going back a few years with people like HD, Dan in Victoria and others I’ve lost track of. It’s becoming somewhat scary. Would not blame you from packing it in. There are some very ungrateful people out there.

#256 Smoking Man on 03.29.16 at 11:19 pm

When God is felling brave

https://youtu.be/v2AC41dglnM

#257 SydCixel on 03.29.16 at 11:20 pm

Garth, I agree with #22 Scott when he writes that the simplest way to address this problem is to close the comments section. I glance through and rarely find anything of merit.

#258 Garth M on 03.29.16 at 11:21 pm

Hey, I don’t really ever comment much, but thought I would say that your blog has helped my family make some really great financial decisions. Thank you so much! Why not just take a break from writing for a bit. A vacation can do wonders!

#259 Future Expatriate on 03.29.16 at 11:27 pm

You need to block those people the way I had to block over 1000 rabid Bernard Sanders supporters-without-a-clue on FB.

Just do it. It will feel good, and your life will improve.

#260 oldmac on 03.29.16 at 11:27 pm

Keep educating Garth. The country needs it; even more so when it doesn’t think it does.

As someone who has hit the wall many times in the past, sometimes you need to know when to dial it back. But for the sake of the rest of em’ – don’t turn it off.

#261 VanDammeCouver on 03.29.16 at 11:28 pm

I don’t know what I would do without this blog. I look forward to it every day, it’s how I relax in the evening after a long day of work. Always informative and hilarious. I’m literally sad on Saturday because I know there’s no post to look forward to.

I’m serious, how pathetic is that Garth? Please keep posting

#262 Love my Kia on 03.29.16 at 11:29 pm

#55 Smoking Man

Ever since the election the Wacked out lefties have invaded the comment section. Rabid rasists entitled victims.

It’s that much fun anymore.
****************************
Laugh of the day. T2 is welcoming refugees. Please explain how this makes lefties racist?

All the crap racism is coming from the ranks of the right. One needs to look no further than at Trump followers.

Garth I would welcome disabling comments just to force Smokey to get himself a life.

#263 james on 03.29.16 at 11:31 pm

“Most countries no longer have walls around them”

Uh, evidence for this?

Most countries outside of Europe don’t have open borders. Japan, Korea, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Uzbekistan, etc.

Try getting Mexican citizenship. The number of migrants taken by Asian countries probably doesn’t exceed the number of average posts on this blog in a given day.

I’m okay with excoriating people who see only Asian mendacity as the sole cause of Vancouver’s housing woes, but lets not be delusional about how open the world is. The western world is open, but an awful lot of places are not.

#264 Briana on 03.29.16 at 11:33 pm

I look forward to reading your daily blogs Garth. Your amusing perspectives and entertaining explanations on financial issues are so refreshing. From the title on the post, to the perfect picture, and enlightening commentaries… Your blog is not to be missed. Please keep it up!!

#265 M on 03.29.16 at 11:36 pm

Gartho baby…don’t fret.
Look in the history and what do you see ?
..so.. get on with the job and stop whining.
Keep the flag up and soldier on baby !

PS Most of the losers are the ones indebted beyond imagination. Why do you have any expectations from those ? They are the scum of the society to begin with. The nasty comments just confirm it.

#266 Victor V on 03.29.16 at 11:40 pm

The pen is mightier than the bored.

#267 DON on 03.29.16 at 11:40 pm

The comments section has become more and more off topic – like a lobby in a movie theater before the main event.

Keep it clean people, enough with the bashing comments and no need for racists comments, if you want something go work for it.

More and more frustrated folks out there…could the main event be around the corner.

thanks for all your advice, teaching etc – much appreciated.

#268 Shahid on 03.29.16 at 11:47 pm

Garth, please don’t give in to the haters.

If need be, disable comments. But don’t punish the rest of us.

#269 Cici on 03.29.16 at 11:54 pm

Well, I also love this blog, mostly for the humorous dose of daily sanity that I need in this insane world.

But the comments section lately does definitively suck, and is even downright frightening. While there are a few voices I love, I wouldn’t cry if you shut the comments down.

#270 West Coast on 03.29.16 at 11:54 pm

Dorothy – please take Garth on a holiday! Garth- please close down for a while! We’ll all break out in a collective rash, but so what.
The reason Garth wades thru all our less than scintillating comments is that he truly wants to weed out hurtful and vicious remarks. We really don’t deserve such conscientious monitoring.
Garth – it’s time to take a break – head south – head north – head east – hell you could even head out west (although I’m sure that would be your last choice).
Whatever you decide to do; many, many thanks for years of great financial advice.
If you say goodbye to us for the month of April, I’m sure we’ll all be much better behaved in May. A form of ‘bark busters’ for blog dogs.

#271 Alan Dee on 03.30.16 at 12:02 am

Garth.
Putting racism aside, Canada has a huge trade imbalance with China for 20 years now. All that money we are sending there has to come back. That is just economics, its not racism. Canadian dollars are worthless in China. Since we have nothing else to sell them, they are buying our real estate. For a variety of reasons, their preferred place is BC.

Plus in the last 10 years the CAD has fallen 30% against CNY. Why is that so hard for you, or anyone else, to understand??? With the collapse in oil, we have even less to sell to export to China, so yet more money will pour into real estate.

#272 Bank of Millennial on 03.30.16 at 12:03 am

Garth, are our banks now getting into issuing their own sub-prime debt? CWBs most recent spread is wider than the grand canyon.

“Preferred Shares will be entitled to receive quarterly floating dividends, as and when declared by the Board of Directors of CWB, equal to the 90-day Government of Canada Treasury Bill rate plus 547 basis points.”

http://www.marketwired.com/press-release/cwb-announces-nvcc-preferred-share-offering-tsx-cwb-2104847.htm

#273 Steve on 03.30.16 at 12:04 am

When you set out to set people straight you become a target. They say the nice thing about banging your head against the wall it feels so good when you stop. Don’t be a people pleaser. You are addicted to this blog so you will never stop. You have not been strung up….yet. But be assured we will be the first there to cut the rope and get you down.

#274 rainclouds on 03.30.16 at 12:10 am

Me probably 10th generation. east coaster, Living in Van.

Inlaws are Chinese Canadian and have welcomed me in their family.Her Parents worked 7 days a week for 40+ years,never sick, raised 5 productive children . Typical for immigrants.

This blog is positive, informative and I thank you for taking the time to educate.

We can’t let the jerks win.

#275 family beagle on 03.30.16 at 12:12 am

Bit of a dilemma. Anytime I’m rattled, I go see the kid with the booth, “PsYcHiAtRiC HeLp 5¢”.

That which we cannot control, we fear. Seems you have control. I hope you stick around. You’re certainly a national enigma. Maybe try a moderator.

#276 B Riding Dirty on 03.30.16 at 12:22 am

Garth, Site hits bang on and off. But just like baseball .500 average is all-star. You have a solid star average. Dont let the heckling fans get to you.

Not saying pull a Tiger Woods and take it out on 5 star whores. But dont take it out by quieting.

That means the herd has won.

I took your advice on how to buy in YVR in this crazy time. I called up the owner of a home in langley that in the sales pitch on mls said first time on the market original owners. Googled the address and home owners name and number came up.

Tried to give them my sad story, the struggle, unfortunately the husband answered, we talked for ten mins, swapped stories he told me good luck bidding.

But I tried and will not give up, hope the same for you!

#277 Little Dipper on 03.30.16 at 12:22 am

Garth, you can add my voice to the chorus of appreciative readers who would be deeply disappointed if you stopped posting. Like many of your readers, I do not fully share your worldview or values; however, I respect and value your insights, analysis, humour, and integrity–I also share your love of animals. And, I think it speaks very highly of you and your body of work, that readers from all across the political spectrum are so clearly addicted to this blog.

#278 LilyJoe~ on 03.30.16 at 12:24 am

Love the posts Garth, please keep it up. I appreciate your advice & perspective :)

#279 crazed and a littlr confused on 03.30.16 at 12:27 am

Hi garth,

I learned quire a bit of finance ie ETf and stocks but even though I think you are wrong on real estate . Not because I think you are illogical but its a cult here in YVR. no one here does any math. it is what I have that you don’t.

the comments can only affect you…if you let it. if a dog is barking . just walk away w/o emotion attachment.
knowing you you would probably prefer the dog barking other some hateful comments…huh

#280 Fortune500 on 03.30.16 at 12:31 am

Remember the 1% of internet comments rule. The vast vast majority do not even bother to put fingers to keyboards. The bulk of people you help and encourage never actually write here. Those of us that do back away when the even smaller percentage decide to get personal or racist. Keep up the good fight Garth, we need you.

With that being said, I do think that the older generation of Canadians need to acknowledge the effects of what housing prices and other macroeconmic policies in Canada are doing to those under 40 crowd. Denial will only lead to more radical responses (HAM is real, whether politically correct or not).

We need to address all elephants in the room. White, black, yellow, or wrinkled and try to make Canada one that is for all Canadians.

If you are young and frustrated, do something worthwhile like helping to support Generation Squeeze or a like minded organization. Get off your butt and out of the basement and call for meaningful change.

#281 Michael on 03.30.16 at 12:32 am

All those arms and legs
would join together in the lack of day
and cry Garth’s blog has gone away!

Thank you brother Garth for your tireless efforts!
I have grown and learned because you shared.
To you I am very thankful, all my best!.

#282 Jamie Fieldman on 03.30.16 at 12:34 am

So, it’s agree with your naive protracted ‘save the whales’ campaign and become a card carrying Liberal Party Bozo who worships Justin, or nothing?

The fact is Garth, the media is a lie distributor. You have often admitted that you wanted to express your opinion over the facts. Do you really think that every Canadian is happy about being bound by the gag laws protecting Trudeau’s Charter of Tears?

We’re tired of having the Liberal ideology shoved down our throats, the truth is not hate.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2016-03-28/top-german-journalist-admits-mainstream-media-completely-fake-we-all-lie-cia

You’ve been told many times your ‘Holy Liberal Bible’ would be challenged and someday come back and bite you in the ass. And you say you’re tired of listening to people express an opinion other than the one you want to impress upon them?

Good Luck with that Garth. Canada is closer to revolution than it is capitulation. I’m will to say that the guillotines come out the first time Trudy asks for 100% taxation in the name of Liberal values.

#283 604renter on 03.30.16 at 12:34 am

Akkkkkkkkkk! No. !! Hang in there Garth. You are a voice of sanity and reason. A voice in the wilderness ? Yes. So was Churchill. Hang in there please. You are a bastion of hope for the sensible and reasonable. Time will prove you right. And – you set a good example for all of us

#284 Fed-up on 03.30.16 at 12:39 am

Garth has done a great job with this blog and I try to read his posts every week. He is a highly educated man, a talented writer and most of all, he is very stern and unwavering in his opinions, view points and beliefs and perhaps this is where the discussion in the comments section reaches its boiling point.

Garth, this is your blog and of course it is yours to moderate and control in any way you see fit. But immediately branding almost everyone who has a differing opinion as an idiot, racist, xenophobe or entitled cry baby, regardless of how eloquently they present their viewpoint, will ruffle more than a few feathers.

Many feel their country has sold down them river by its leaders with no regard for those who live, work and die here. They are disenfranchised, frustrated and feel a deep despair in the fact that they may never have what they’re wrinkly parents easily attained regardless of how much money they are earning. Ridiculing them, telling them to move, accusing them of racism and jealousy only cranks up the temperatures.

Maybe we need to listen a bit more rather pulling out the race card and name calling shenanigans to shut down the discussions that make the politically hyper-sensitive uncomfortable. Feeding the trolls? Absolutely not. Inviting intelligent discussion and avoid dismissing eloquent and valid counterpoints? I would suggest, yes.

But again, it is your blog sir.

Peace out.

#285 Neo Anderson on 03.30.16 at 12:43 am

Thanks for all your hard work Garth. Do what you gotta do. Just keep the blog running.

#286 Westvan on 03.30.16 at 12:43 am

Oh it the annual behave or else post…. Why not just shut the comments down if you feel it’s become a sounding board for the kkk to recruit from.

#287 Upenuff on 03.30.16 at 12:43 am

Keep it going Garth…. way too many people care about what you have to say on your blog. Everyone has to remember the Canadian Dollar is not racist…. it loves everyone and wants everyone to touch it!!!

#288 Moneyfroma$ia on 03.30.16 at 12:44 am

Garth! LOL, if you quit now, you will never be right about a housing correction… Love it!

#289 Hamcouver on 03.30.16 at 12:52 am

Hi Garth
Grateful for the sound financial advice. Listen to your wife- Apple has a lot of unhappy couples to answer for with their amazing gadgets….which equates to never being truly “off” from work. Cull the comments if necessary.
But please keep blogging…. I wish I had found this blog sooner. Your advice has been spot on for this immigrant family.

#290 piperdoctor on 03.30.16 at 12:53 am

Keep up the good work, Garth. I get my evening chuckle most nights reading this while I brush my teeth… I have abandoned the comments section for the most part.

#291 Doug t on 03.30.16 at 12:53 am

Ego is a horrible thing – it controls and it destroys – let it go Garth – you don’t need this daily attention – you’ve done enough – let go – be at ease with who you really are – don’t live for the fawning it’s not worth it

#292 I'm Still Around on 03.30.16 at 1:02 am

Skeptics and critics will always be there but there are thousands of people who read this blog daily and appreciate everything you’ve done to help educate and raise awareness on personal finance issues!! Thank you Garth!!

#293 Just Jack on 03.30.16 at 1:02 am

I seldom post. I have chosen to do so this time to show my solidarity.

#294 juno on 03.30.16 at 1:21 am

#10

That’s right its our own government whom allow the abuse on our system.

I’m Chinese, been here for over 35 years and pay my taxes which I don’t mind paying.

I know lots of Chinese people who plays our system well. It’s well knownto the community , not only to the Chinese but all foreigners where the loopholes are.

1) back in the olden days people from would come over from other countries and give birth to their kids in Canada,

– this gave them Canadian citizenship
– later on when they grew up they will come back to the country … as Canadian citizen (even though they lived in another country all their lives.
to get a free education. Some come here because they were too weak in their country to move forward with the education some come here because our universities are subsides by the government with grants and loans which may never get paid back.
3) other take advantage of our welfare system. They move around so much its hard to track where they are most goes back to their country and collects the cheques. Having others report for them and may show up in Canada for a short duration of time. (I’ve seen this happen many times and it gets me angry) But its part of the game.

Others gets their pension from a foreign country and takes advantage of the additional$$$ from our system.

I wish this would stop but our system is broken and is taken advantage of. Don’t see an end to this until the money runs dry

#295 kommykim on 03.30.16 at 1:29 am

It sounds like Garth is having his very own “GOP vs Trump” epiphany.

#296 bob on 03.30.16 at 1:32 am

You should report these threats to police. Hopefully they will be dealt with.

#297 Original dave on 03.30.16 at 1:35 am

The people need you G. Your purpose must be bigger than you realize. You will go down in the books as a truly great great Canadian for your service.

I don’t have any other blogs that I set out time in my evenings to read :(

#298 Entrepreneur on 03.30.16 at 1:58 am

Maybe shorten the comment section; maybe shorten your days to 2 to 3; maybe take the summer off.

Could not believe how you can keep writing a blog almost every second day with hardly any days off.

One of the things that one special teacher taught was to listen to everyone so nothing (most of the time) gets under my skin. I get to the bottom of all problems and I am good at it. I have helped many children and adults and bypass their level of thinking but with reasoning and facts to make it clear and understanding.

We all love this blog GT but sometimes a change is in the call.

#299 Maik on 03.30.16 at 2:03 am

Hey Garth Iam just writting to support you and to encourage you to keep deleting and keep your blog open. I have learned so much from your blog… I also have laugh.. Do not let the evil dwarfs and negative jerks win…they will always exists…and at the end of days and years…the only things that matters is how much good you have done for your readers and how long you stood up besides all the haters and negative jerks…so do not let them win…keep doing what you do many of us appreciated it and learn from your articles, you also give us data to research and learnd more…. Thanks for all your free service.

#300 Apple Pi on 03.30.16 at 2:14 am

It’s really now wonder why some blogs like Daring Fireball don’t do comments any longer. As an option you could always disable the WordPress comments and replace it with one requiring a Facebook login. People forced to comment under their name are less likely to post hate.

#301 Freedom First on 03.30.16 at 2:17 am

#254 NoOneOfConsequence

Congratulations to you! And to your family also! For without their support, this would not have been possible.
I’m impressed.

#302 H. Marshall on 03.30.16 at 2:21 am

Losers always have to find someone to blame for their perceived difficulties.

If you can’t afford a house in Vancouver, then it isn’t the worse thing that can happen to you in this world.

#303 hunter on 03.30.16 at 2:24 am

Quite honestly, this blog saved us from financial suicide.

Thank you Garth, truly.

#304 Bla bla bla on 03.30.16 at 2:30 am

FED can’t raise rates.

#305 My dog has issues on 03.30.16 at 2:32 am

Sounds like your Wife wants more quality time with you. My woman was just yelling at me to shut my phone off and try to sleep but now she’s snoring :) Got a quick post in!

#306 Mark Down Under on 03.30.16 at 2:48 am

I haven’t read your blog for a while, came by just to check in and Bam! I come mostly for the pictures, anyway… just kidding.

Be a shame if you gave up. Explore the options. I don’t always agree with you, but that’s not a requirement. What we DO agree on is avoiding the madness that is housing lust. Hard to do in a land weary from housing propaganda.

My father was an immigrant to Canada, I have emmigrated to Australia. The housing lust scene is no different here, so many have their eyes set on just one asset class.

Have to say, though, that some of Smoking Man’s comments could cause cancer. Maybe there should be a warning of some kind?

#307 Greg on 03.30.16 at 2:52 am

I appreciate the work you do, Garth, and I hope you won’t succumb to these people that post hateful things. I think a better comment moderating system would work well for the greaterfool, like disqus, where you allow better moderating, and users can upvote or downvote comments (like reddit). There are too many trolls on the internet, and we need to axe some of these silly comments, especially “FIRST!!” Argh!

Keep your head up.

#308 Captain Yankee on 03.30.16 at 3:00 am

First, thank you Garth for the 2,283 insightful & reasoned posts about economics, money, real estate and the road ahead; I don’t know where I would stay abreast of current events if not for your updates on local and international issues. Second, so very,very sorry for the 412,039 comments. To moderate the internet is a Sisyphean task. The comments (I only read ones you reply to for a chuckle) seem to be the drag of it so perhaps there is a way to thin out the herd or perhaps by just doing away with the comments. Most are self-aggrandizing blather anyway.
(275 so far as I write this on the W coast.)

I sincerely hope you continue and would understand if you stopped.

Who would shine a beacon in the darkness if you stop?
Cheers Garth
Jason

#309 Thank you Dorothy on 03.30.16 at 5:02 am

Most days start with reading your column. And some of those mornings include Lucinda. I am a fan of both. Since last October, I mostly avoid the comment section, skimming by most of it. As one other person wrote, it is the equivalent of graffiti. Or worse, it has become a forum for people to perpetuate negativity, and a strong sense of separateness. No good comes from that. Please discontinue the comments. Dorothy knows best.

#310 A wise man once said on 03.30.16 at 6:56 am

The anger is misdirected and not actual racism. In my opinion.

The abuse you take is in service of your country. At least you’re not hated like Harper is.

The spousal stress is tough, sorry to hear about it. You’ve been a… I’m going to use your verbiage now… ‘Successful’ guy most of your life. This sheltered your wife from serious want. For the periods of time you guys may not have had a lot of money, you had enough and she had the benefit of your guidance. Not to mention more quaint times, which as you correctly surmised, had Canada protected from unfair competition and thus presented more opportunity. Your wife had less worry than most wives today. She has been, in more than one way, sheltered.

What I would say to her is this: I’m sorry you had to read the kind of comments Garth usually deletes. But be grateful you never had to love the life that gives rise to the kind of unhappiness that generates comments like that. Don’t be mad at them. Feel sorry for them because they got the short end of the globalization stick. And now they act like bigots because they can’t better articulate their hurt. But they’re hurting. And the financier and CEO class have caused this. The so called job creators have caused this. Governments asleep at the wheel have caused this. Greed has caused this. But they blame foreigners because that’s all they can do to lash out right now. At least they don’t have a Trump to vote for, like our neighbours to the south.

#311 A wise man once said on 03.30.16 at 7:00 am

be grateful you never had to LIVE the life

Not love the life.

Typo, sorry.

#312 BobC on 03.30.16 at 7:04 am

I’m not sure you and the Mrs. understand the good you do with the Greater Fool. I have to agree with a lot of other comments on here. Take a good vacation. A good one, not a weekend getaway. Delete more or have someone trained by you to delete them. Just don’t rob us of your knowledge and wisdom. I, for one, have learned so much. Thank you for doing what you do.

#313 Dan on 03.30.16 at 7:19 am

About bloody time. Good for you Mr. Turner.

#314 Bonhomme Carnaval on 03.30.16 at 7:23 am

Yesterday was a sad day.

Jean Lapierre’s untimely and tragic passing and GT contemplating putting his blog to sleep…

I hope today will be a better day.

Cheers

#315 fancy_pants on 03.30.16 at 7:26 am

Garth,

I have been a faithful visitor of your site since the early days. Your warnings were correct, it was the gov’t that set the stage to spite those warnings that has been wrong – we just haven’t tasted the consequences (yet).

Any anger or blame from should be directed at one self for not playing the ‘game’ presented, or to the maker of the rules of the game (the gov’t), but not to the players of the game. Being aware of the playing field is a plus, hating the players on the field are a minus.

All the best to you and yours, whatever you choose to do. I know I would have shut the doors long ago. I understand where you are coming from; life is too short, at some point you want to put the shovel down. I hope you have at least churned some business b/c of this blog or sold more books.

Thanks for all your time and dedication.

ps. you realize as soon as you shut down the blog, no sooner will RE tank. Murphy’s law. maybe you can time that to your advantage.

#316 pBrasseur on 03.30.16 at 7:29 am

Hello Garth!

I understand your frustration, but frankly you of all people should know how effective anonymous blogs are to attract idiots and weirdos.

That’s why we have moderation and I encourage you to use it as much as necessary to keep the discussion civil and at a level you (and your wife) are comfortable with. Just delete the posts that don’t meet that standard and don’t even bother to say «deleted».

Your contribution is unique and appreciated, this blog is both fun and interesting and I hope you will keep doing it (but nobody forces you to write every single day…). Besides, it would be a shame for you to stop doing what you like because of a few morons. So please don’t.

#317 mitzerboy aka queencitykid on 03.30.16 at 7:31 am

hi garth
we need your words of wisdom out here

sticks and stones can break your bones
but words can never hurt you

#318 Joe on 03.30.16 at 7:34 am

Garth, if you decide to keep comments you’ll probably need to approve every commenter before they can even post comments. Your idea of banning IPs is simple but ineffective considering all the ways one can change their IP and there are billions of IPs out there. It’s just unworkable.

#319 BeeBop on 03.30.16 at 7:47 am

QE BOC starting April 1, 2016

#320 Mauri on 03.30.16 at 7:57 am

The obvious question is why are people so angry ?

The government has always tried to divide the working class. We have not benefited from increased productivity,
Automation , etc

See Bbc article
Why are Americans so angry?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-35406324

#321 James Taggart on 03.30.16 at 8:11 am

Priceless. This blog is.

Make no mistake Garth, your insights and commitement to this Crusade of yours are most valued.

Most of us are perfectly aware that daily news is extremely narrow, biased, and full of puff pieces of little permanent importance. Besides, we are constantly distracted from the most important cues of economic reality by the intervention of interpreters, pundits, explainers, spin-doctors and all manner of experts who tell us that what we hear or see is no really as it appears. Even when we hear through the noise, dismiss the interpreters and actually notice an event, we simply may not have the background of knowledge to comprehend – to connect the dots as it were.

Truth is, without this blog most of us – blog dawgs – would be lost, literally.

Although we may, now and then, encounter ungentlemanly comments and/or replies while reading the comments section, I think this blog would not be the same without this financially-themed “cathartic caucus”.

#322 maxx on 03.30.16 at 8:18 am

Completely agree. Life is far too short.
Each and every one of us has won the lottery of minuscule odds of life in a vast universe.
We won the right to see the light of day.
To my mind, the point of it all is to enjoy every single bit. To see and acknowledge its beauty.
Everything else is simply sustenance and pouring vitriol into that incomparable gift is the greatest tragedy of all.

#323 Grantmi on 03.30.16 at 8:22 am

Simple. .. to post your comments here you must enter your Facebook or linked-in account. Solved.

#324 Dave on 03.30.16 at 8:22 am

Just want to pipe up as a faithful reader that I always enjoy reading your blog even if I don’t always agree with your opinions. Please don’t let the idiots get you down. Thanks for moderating the comments section, it must take a whack of precious time. I’ll keep reading as long as you keep writing.

#325 RB on 03.30.16 at 8:40 am

Garth, thanks for sharing your wisdom. It’s greatly appreciated.

#326 Erin on 03.30.16 at 8:59 am

After reading some of the comments people leave here I can only imagine the nutters you delete. For what it’s worth, I believe there are far more of us that enjoy and appriciate your blog that don’t generally leave comments (like myself) than the sad few that spend their lives filled with hate and sadly a desperate need to share their thoughts.

#327 Pawel Terek on 03.30.16 at 9:03 am

As always, funny, articulate and thought provoking…could not agree more with your views on hateful comments. Glad to hear that you’ll be taking some actions. Keep up the good work!

#328 Leslie on 03.30.16 at 9:06 am

Hey garth this is legit…I think you just found out what society is becoming… unless they are better or the same than everyone else they will look to hate and destroy . Sad and scary . People don’t realize no one deserves anything and it can all be taken away without notice

#329 yogi on 03.30.16 at 9:07 am

Garth, my wife and I have gladly followed your advice, sold house, invested profit, and now rent. We live in Calgary and see the hardship everyday. You are doing so much for so many, don’t let the “assholes” and trolls get you down – just ban em! That’s how the internet works ;)

#330 Leslie on 03.30.16 at 9:16 am

Maybe let people apply for commenting privilege. Must write a paragraph on investing strategy .
Comments are very good if people are talking about legit ideas..
We should create a group just talks about fiance and investing with people who are interested in learning and improving

#331 broader mind on 03.30.16 at 9:31 am

“Please,Sir,I Want Some More”—————- Obvious outpouring of Love in the comments ———-Let Dorothy know your truly needed.

#332 dovie on 03.30.16 at 9:37 am

garth…I have read your blog everyday ,even re-read when you take a break and it amazes me to think that Canada is made up of immigrants from everywhere!!! and yet we also have bigots and prejudiced (to use your perfect words)assholes who come to this wonderful blog to fluff their feathers…we all know who they are if we read the comments but much of the time ,I am able to pass their s$#t and just read where you have offered comments to someone….please don’t shut down your blog…I am addicted as so many others to your wealth of knowledge that you so generously share with all of us financial illiterates….I make about 40,000. per year and since reading your blog have been able to top up my tfsa,(it is not just for the rich!!!!)start a self-directed unregistered,and continued to faithfully add to my growing rrsp account ….I don’t know how my retirement will go(2 years to work yet) but every cent I can manage is going someplace useful and I will pat you on the back for that….there are so many more that I have sent to your blog for guidance as well…take a break and for sure block the comments forever if necessary but please beg your wonderful Dorothy who shares you with us to allow you to continue teaching us….thanks for all you do for so many of us…we owe you so much and you are so dear to our hearts…love ya

#333 RB on 03.30.16 at 9:42 am

Keep your chin up, mate! You do good work.

#334 Vivek on 03.30.16 at 9:47 am

Don’t give up!!!

Keep the blog alive!

Your blog rocks. You also have supporters. People who blame others for their own failings and inability to succeed have always existed and will always exist. Also, there are many trolls who just get a kick out of posting non sense so as to initiate endless pointless debates.

You talk in a rational logical manner which implies that 99% of people can never understand what is being discussed. People are illogical and governed by what they “feel” or want. Logic has no place for most people. The concept of “cheap” money driving up real estate is VERY hard to comprehend. Hence, most people will blame anything and everything.

My usage of the number 99% is to make a point and also based on life experience that most people like logical arguments only when these support their own views and will simply get rid of any facts that contradicts their “version” of reality.

Keep the blog alive!

#335 Centre Wing on 03.30.16 at 9:53 am

I’ve learned so much from reading this blog the past several months. Perhaps you could create a private FB page where only approved members could comment. After all, it’s a lot harder to remain anonymous when it’s your real name being used.

#336 T. Garrod on 03.30.16 at 9:59 am

Garth – I never comment, but I have been reading your post everyday for over 4 years, haven’t missed a single one. Your knowledge is invaluable to us, please keep it up. I stopped reading the comments section years ago – too many crazies out there. Please don’t stop posting. If anything close the comments section (like others have mentioned) or a registered comments section only. Thanks again.

#337 Smoking Man on 03.30.16 at 10:00 am

They’re on to us

http://metro.co.uk/2014/12/01/aliens-wearing-human-suits-visited-casinos-in-las-vegas-author-claims-4969761/

#338 DM in C on 03.30.16 at 10:04 am

I have read this blog since day 1, and before that, your columns. I appreciate all you do to spread your financial messages.

If you choose to continue, perhaps a registration format for commenting is required. It will help weed some (but def not all) of the crap out. But there are professional shit-stirrers who will leak in. Use comment rating system to flag them too. Make life easier for you, anyway.

Good luck with the decision. Thanks.

#339 Simon on 03.30.16 at 10:05 am

Hey Garth,

The articles you post are interesting and it would be a shame if you ceased publication.

How about simply disabling comments for a while?

#340 Yanniel on 03.30.16 at 10:12 am

Cuban immigrant here. I was completely broke when I came to this country. I never asked for government help or any other help. I worked (legally) in many things (carpenter, plumber, constructor, roofer, farmer and more); now I work in my profession, Software Engineer. I have paid my taxes, all of them.

Now, I am Canadian; I am proud of being so. This is a great country, with freedom and the opportunity to fend for yourself. Opportunity and freedom, you see, is a rare thing in some places of this world.

I say all this, not to brag about myself, but to stress the fact that immigrants struggle a lot in this new land. If we manage to make a decent living, it’s because we have worked our asses off. I do personally know lots of immigrants from different nationalities. None of which was rich before coming here.

Your blog Mr Garth has taught me more about Canada than anything else. I am grateful for that. My hard work was not enough, reading your blog pointed me on the right path.

Thank you.

Yanniel.

#341 Alberta Ed on 03.30.16 at 10:14 am

Pay no attention to the crazies. This blog has done more to educate people about critical financial issues than any other source available. Fire up the Harley and take Dorothy out for lunch.

#342 Alram on 03.30.16 at 10:15 am

Thank you Garth for all you do! You are someone I respect for your financial smarts, witty and clever writing, proud patriotism and big heart. Add me to the list of every day readers and very rare commenters who would miss my daily dose of Greater Fool. We who live in Canada should be ever grateful for winning the Geographical Lottery. We are all immigrants and have tremendous opportunity to learn, earn and live free in Canada. Who are we to begrudge this opportunity for others. With gratitude.

#343 Penny Henny on 03.30.16 at 10:26 am

If you live to hate people, start your own damn blog. If you want me to choose between this site and my wife, just keep it up.-GT

Considering you spend hours a day moderating the comments wouldn’t it be fair to say you’ve made that choice already?

#344 Big Buckets of Liberal Party propaganda on 03.30.16 at 10:29 am

DELETED

#345 TurnerNation on 03.30.16 at 10:34 am

400th? Real news is Dollarama stock up huge on earnings today. Dollar store nation. T2 Stores.

Huge price inflation at Dollarama. Items I bought for $1 now are 25% higher at $1.25.

#346 calgary64 on 03.30.16 at 10:35 am

i vote for closing the comments section as well. i come here to hear you not anyone else.

#347 Renter's Revenge! on 03.30.16 at 10:36 am

Sometimes I think I’m going crazy, then I read the comments on this blog and realize just how sane I still am. You need the bad in order to see the good.

I say freedom of speech should be maintained to the greatest extent possible (threats and libel excluded).

#348 Victoria on 03.30.16 at 10:56 am

Please stay – you are keeping many people sane.

#349 Noel on 03.30.16 at 10:57 am

I too find the racism and misogyny on the comments section very distasteful, but its usually only from a handful of commentors (of the stuff that gets through).

But, that’s what happens when you have a free discussion and let any sad, lonely loser access to the internet and a keyboard.

Good luck with the moderation.

#350 FloridaMan on 03.30.16 at 11:04 am

Would hate to see the blog go; one alternative might be turning off comments entirely; the folks who confuse “free speech” with “you have to show my comments on your website” can, as you suggest, start their own damn blog. It’s a free country (countries, really–greetings from Way Down South…)

#351 Ryan the Thirtysomething on 03.30.16 at 11:05 am

As others have said, the vast majority of us appreciate what you do every day and don’t often comment. Maybe do just the blog and not have a comment section? I doubt many would miss it.

Or have some kind of account registration where people need a legitimate verified email address to post. And their mother’s email address.

#352 Burton on 03.30.16 at 11:16 am

Hi Garth,
The comments you get are just a sign of the times we live in. People are fed up and this is a backlash against political correctness. Everybody is so easily offended that there is no public discourse possible without offending someone. While some comments are offensive to shut down the comment section would do your blog a disservice. I find the comment section the most interesting and educational part of this blog. If people are offended they need to get over it and learn how to filter out the negativity. What has happened to free speech?

#353 Prince Polo on 03.30.16 at 11:24 am

Hi Garth!
I was wondering what was going on with all of the commentary lately – seems people have gone nuts. Turns out, they were nuts all along and the Gartho-filter was saving the rest of humanity from the insanity. Thanks for all of the good work you do on a daily basis, trying to warn us of the dangers of imbalance. Please don’t shutter this blog. You are a true gem!

#354 LP on 03.30.16 at 11:24 am

Hi Garth

I don’t know what the answer is to the comments section problem. I DO know that it’s not possible to “unread” anything that your eyes see. I’m pretty certain it’s not possible to “unhear” the hate-filled, cynical, misogynistic, and sometimes racist stuff that tries to pass for intellectual discourse on this blog.

I had stopped reading most of the commentary a few months ago then came back to skimming it in the hope of finding some of the witty repartee, genuine wise contributions etc of just a few short years ago. (Some of you will remember Bill from Muskoka, Pecked to Death by Ducks, the Cat Lady, Live Within Your Means and many more.)

Anyway, whatever your decision, it will/must be the best one for you. It will allay Dorothy’s fears for your sanity if she knows you’re not reading a steady diet of garbage throughout every day.

For me, I’ll miss the dog columns, the very rare patriotic posts and even your occasional rants. Today, I’m not going to hide behind my usual initials and will proudly use my name.

Linda Pearson
F68ON

#355 A Canadian Abroad on 03.30.16 at 11:25 am

“There is before us, a large societal movement, one in which, cannot be ignored or dismissed. I see before us a change, a change so large that you must stand up and be accounted for or be sundered by it.”

People are mad. They need a place to voice and vent. Closing GF blog won’t stop the movement. Glad Garth is a bit of a pressure valve allowing us to post here vs the countless media sites that post bias news stories and close their comment sections to ridicule.

#356 For those about to flop... on 03.30.16 at 11:32 am

#344 TurnerNation on 03.30.16 at 10:34 am
400th? Real news is Dollarama stock up huge on earnings today. Dollar store nation. T2 Stores.

Huge price inflation at Dollarama. Items I bought for $1 now are 25% higher at $1.25.

////////////////////////////////////

Hey T.N,I was at the dollar store buying earphones for my phone ,should have been 1.40…. 1.25 plus tax.
They charged me 1.85 , I was curious as it is a dollar store so I looked at the bill.
45 cent environmental fee which works out roughly to be a third of the price.

These are the rises most of us can afford,cable,hydro and phone bills that is another story…

M41BC

#357 Eldon on 03.30.16 at 11:35 am

Garth

I for one love your blog and your insightful information. Dont casher in. Your advice is just that… advice. People in this wonderful country have the freedom of choice to do whatever the hell they want. Dont let a few crazies wreck the great work that you have done. Please! Keep up the good work. Thank you.

#358 cramar on 03.30.16 at 11:44 am

Wow! I’m off for a day, and the sky falls in! I’ve wondered how long Garth was going to to put up with all the comment nonsense.

There is middle ground between time wasted in editing the comments, and completely shutting down the blog. That is to disable comments completely!

Garth, you have the number one financial blog in Canada! Maybe even the whole world! It is a needed voice of sanity crying in the financial wilderness. People NEED to know the information presented here. They need to know there is a source of light amidst the darkness. A source of reason in a society of delusion. I hope you can continue to do so as a public service.

Comments on your analysis are really not necessary.

#359 Panhead on 03.30.16 at 11:49 am

Jeez …Where else would all the whiners out here in 604land go to whine without you Garth? A few of us are happy to live out here without whining though. Just a quick suggestion to make the blog a wee bit better again … how bout a scotty dog pic? Keep yer stick on the ice …

#360 Ban Keywords on 03.30.16 at 11:50 am

Ban these keywords:

HAM, China, Chinese, immigration, Foreign money, Vancouver.

Discussion around these issues should be banned and labelled a crime. I’m sure Christy Clark would approve.

#361 Ban Keywords on 03.30.16 at 11:51 am

And ban the words Christy Clark, Mourneau, Flaherty, F, T2, Trudeau while we’re at it.

#362 Ben on 03.30.16 at 11:54 am

Hi Garth,
I’m going to add to the pile on here, to say thanks for writing, and please keep it up! You provide, by far, the most reasonable financial advice anyone has ever received for free. I have read your pathetic blog daily since 2009, and have noticed a decline in comment quality, to the point where I never read them anymore. I remember when I was young and impressionable, reading the discussion points in the comments provided additional ideas and clarification of the day’s lesson; now it’s just a cesspool of racism and misinformation from the haters. With the exception of Smoking Man, who has been a loyal patron of this section for years, please do shut down the ignorant comments and keep things on topic. Thanks for writing, please keep it up!

#363 Deky on 03.30.16 at 11:58 am

Keep up the good work Garth and don’t pay attention to mean and evil individuals.

#364 james on 03.30.16 at 12:01 pm

#339 Simon on 03.30.16 at 10:05 am
Hey Garth,
The articles you post are interesting and it would be a shame if you ceased publication.
How about simply disabling comments for a while?
____________________________________________
Hello Garth,
The disabling comments for a while sounds enticing however there is always some small tidbit of knowledge out there.
Why not just keep us all on track with a zero tolerance of anything racist, anti-women, and anti-men, anti-homosexual, anti-immigrant. As well just to keep it clean eliminate sociopaths, psychopaths, conspiracy theorists, and individuals who promote themselves and or their own agenda’s or directives. After all we come here to garner knowledge and wisdom from yourself and others with common vested interests. We don’t want rants or stories of individual’s foibles. We want investment and betterment assistance.

#365 IHCTD9 on 03.30.16 at 12:06 pm

#294 juno on 03.30.16 at 1:21 am
#10

That’s right its our own government whom allow the abuse on our system.

I’m Chinese, been here for over 35 years and pay my taxes which I don’t mind paying.

I know lots of Chinese people who plays our system well. It’s well knownto the community , not only to the Chinese but all foreigners where the loopholes are.
__________________________________________

You speak the truth, but don’t let it bother you. Worry about your own future. Pay off your debt, save what you can, and limit your exposure to government. I can guarantee you will be smiling before too long.

I look at T2 policy and shake my head. He has given me a tax break. He’s handed me more child care money and now made it all tax free (I’ll spend it on beer and popcorn :) ). I have a paid for house, 100’s of thousands invested, and no debt whatsoever. T2 gives guys like me handouts, and stick our youth with the bill via a 12 figure projected first term debt increase. I hope you Millennials are happy with your choice, I told you so.

Wynne essentially spends her day contemplating what more she can do for the LGTB’s and to hell with basically everything else. Ontario is a provincial piñata, and Wynne never put the blindfold on. I think everyone here who gave a shit, has pretty much said *#@! it at this point – myself included.

So do like me:

I have recently looked at my habits and spending, and have subsequently eliminated $145.00 per week of unnecessary retail spending. I should have done this long ago, thanks Trudeau/Wynne for getting it to the top of the priority list. No taxes paid on money not spent.

I have committed to buying used on larger purchases. Since the beginning of the year, over 3500.00 was spent non retail. No taxes paid on top of money saved.

Sorry to say it, but some work will be contracted out UTT. What can I say, as I lose hope in government, I care less and less. No taxes paid, thanks TFW program, you know they knew it was going to happen..

I have been pounding it into RRSP’s since mid last year and will be getting a five figure tax return for 2015.

I have made a creative deal for a truckload of surplus wood pellets sufficient for 4 years worth of heating with a guy with a bit of a problem on his hands. Half price, no taxes paid.

I will probably be joining the ranks of the part time, OTS, Kijiji/Ebay manufacturing world cult.

I’m just one guy, and thousands upon thousands worth of Provincial and Federal taxes are not leaving my wallet, and also coming back to my wallet.

That’s what you do Juno, don’t sweat government policy. But don’t pay them either. Your vote only goes so far, the rest you do on your own. Be the laffer curve in action. Don’t waste any time worrying about what others are doing, worry about your own life and goals.

#366 David on 03.30.16 at 12:13 pm

I read your blog every day and truly appreciate the insight you provide. The commentboard isn’t an accurate reflection of the views of your readers. I, for example, never comment as 1. the format of the comment section (chronological order) isn’t conducive to discussion (whereas having threads, upvoting, etc. would help) and 2. I just expect it to be full of trolls (welcome to the Internet). Maybe consider finding volunteer admins to help monitor the comment section?

Just want to say thanks again for your efforts and don’t let the trolls get to you!

#367 Kootenay Ma on 03.30.16 at 12:14 pm

Hi Garth,

and Thank You Dorothy !

Sometimes a line should be drawn, take it up a notch

Haters gotta hate

Bloggers gotta Blog !

Doggers, well my newish Tova, Border Collie-Aussie Shepard mix, sends love to Bandit, and a “wanna play?”

I learn a lot from the comments here too, but I skim past the nasties because I cannot learn from that. Can’t even spend my energy to filter it out. Not new. We all know it. Its everywhere. Just as well to pre-moderate them out.

Otherwise it just perpetuates bad energy and rewards the bad behavior, so they’ll continue, without your guidelines, which I fully back.

The value of your Blog is high, we are grateful for you, and we are happy to enjoy the thoughtful and insightful posts and commenters.

Blog On

#368 fancy_pants on 03.30.16 at 12:17 pm

start feeding the queue with excuses for not raising rates. it will never end; in a race to devalue one’s currency, there is no exit in sight from this merry-go-round.

we blew a tire in ’08. next one we blow an axle or transmission, after that we blow the engine

love your family and pet today, the promise of tomorrow ain’t as rosy

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-29/yellen-says-caution-in-raising-rates-is-especially-warranted-imdmq9pu

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-30/this-chart-shows-just-how-worried-janet-yellen-is-about-the-global-economy

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-30/yellen-outsources-u-s-monetary-policy-to-the-financial-markets

#369 Vivek on 03.30.16 at 12:19 pm

Keep the blog alive!!

P.S. My email address is real even though it looks a bit strange.

#370 AB Boxster on 03.30.16 at 12:19 pm

Intolerance stems from ‘fear’ and ‘ignorance’ (lack of knowledge)

With respect to this issue, I see two kinds of intolerance.

1. Intolerance of the citizenry.
People ‘fear’ that despite having family incomes that are well above the average, they will never be able to afford a home.
They ‘fear’ that their neighborhoods are changing for the worse due to the vacant unkempt properties.
People ‘fear’ that their government is willfully ignoring the issue.

People are ignorant of why this is so.
They hear stories and anecdotes of foreign funds.
They see empty condos and houses.
They see government make no effort to discuss concerns.
They see absurd price increases in real estate that means they will never be able to afford to buy.

And fear and ignorance breeds intolerance.
(See Europe and refugees, and US and Trump)

2. Intolerance of the elected officials

Government ‘fears’ that if they were to really analyze the level of foreign funds in the real estate market, that they ‘might’ find that there is a huge impact.
They ‘fear’ that to even ask the question will bring on accusations of racism and xenophobia from the ‘enlightened’ citizenry.
They ‘fear’ that this information could outrage the electorate which might force them to put policies in place to address it.
They fear that these policies will kill the ‘golden egg’ of housing.
They fear the ‘value’ of their own house will go down.

So they choose to remain happily ignorant of the issue.
Choosing to ignore it and hope it goes away.

The solution is simple.

Find out the facts.
1. Are foreign funds having an impact on the Canadian housing market?
2. If not then fine.
3. If so, then let have debate as to if this a good or bad thing.

Or, we can continue to do the following:
1. Resort to intolerant remarks to support a position.
2. Ignore the underlying issues and describe the intolerant as racist.

#371 BCGirl on 03.30.16 at 12:20 pm

Goodbye Vancouver, you should go and love yourself! This is an entertaining article in the Vancouver Province today. Break up letters to Vancouver! Why so many are leaving and will continue to do so.

http://blogs.theprovince.com/2016/03/28/jennifer-fox-goodbye-vancouver-you-should-go-and-love-yourself/

#372 nubbers on 03.30.16 at 12:20 pm

I am not aware of any other blog in the world, let alone Canada, that does as much to save people from themselves and from the sharks who would dearly love to see this blog shut down.

Maybe have an extra day off, though.

#373 Lorne on 03.30.16 at 12:21 pm

Suggestion: set a limit as to how many comments will be posted each day….50? 100? You can still delete some of those first 50/100 such as “First” and any others that are in bad taste….but once the limit is reached, that’s it for the day…..you can just delete every other one that comes in without reading them. Will certainly cut down on the amount of time you will need to spend on the blog….which is definitely a good idea!
You might also consider how many blogs to post each week.

#374 Silent the people on 03.30.16 at 12:28 pm

Keep up the site! I agree with your escalation of punishment! My mom would be very upset!

Thanks

#375 Paul on 03.30.16 at 12:33 pm

I have been following your blog since you started and started investing in ETF three years ago because of you. Thank you

#376 Fred Kief on 03.30.16 at 12:41 pm

Hello Garth,
You have said it ever so clearly. Most haters are descendants of immigrants themselves.
Fred

#377 Soothsayer on 03.30.16 at 12:42 pm

Keep up the great work Garth and don’t let the morons ruin it for the rest of us.

#378 Don Kreigan on 03.30.16 at 12:44 pm

The real culprits are central banks, banks, lenders and government policies that give people false hope that they can own a house and pay 2% to 3% mortgage rates.

This cheap money has made increased housing prices by 300%, 400% and even some places 500% in the last 20 to 23 years are so.

People are going to be in debt from each generation to another and to another etc. They were tricked, fooled, duped big time.

Socialism in any form does not work and actually makes things much worse. You guys wanted low interest rates now each your lunch.

#379 Billy Bob on 03.30.16 at 12:51 pm

I don’t have time to read much here but scan Garths post
If you want to blame someone blame desperate governments.
ZIRP because the worlds in a messed up state because buy now pay later.
Locals can’t afford to live in Canada so the flood gates are open. They need taxes desperately. Much money is being laundered here from foreign countries.
In my little tiny town on the coast they deported some immigrants for not abiding buy imigration law. Another is building a seafood factory breaking environmental laws and laundering money. I know names and faces.
My wife immigrated here years ago and there were no handouts. Syrian families are being handed stuff.
Nobody gives us shit and WITHOUT guys like me paying $120,000 in taxes yr deadbeats are doomed.
When my business went down know one bailed me out. Not even any EI. Look at Bombarier. No less then 90 requests for tax payer money. And now how much we going to get?! Socialist commie pigs.
This place discust me. My father paid Mega taxes former 5 decades and you know how pathetic his CCP is?
I’m sick as Fk paying for others.
Eventually we run out of other people’s money.
People desperate for yield.
Things ARE SERIUOSLY MESSED UP.
T2 is an idiot. A billion here a billion there.
I know lots of people in need.
Including retires here!

If I have to screw the system to survive the onslaught I will. That’s what many coming here are doing because their rugime is corrupt. I know a chinnese realtor in van that takes her commissions paid off shore in gems and wears them back to Canada to avoide taxes.
I like the blog.

#380 Young Reader on 03.30.16 at 12:53 pm

I’ve read this blog everyday for a year or so. It’s my only daily that I look forward to.

There is so much click-bait, sponsored content and generally bad journalism floating through the web, and sites like this are sorely needed.

The hateful, ignorant commenters are now just a part of the internet. Their voice seems loudest. Most of us quietly appreciate the work and gasp as we scroll through the shameful discourse that occurs.

I hope you continue to provide sound advice and hilarious, well-written reporting.

After yesterday I understand why you would hang it up though…

Thank you.

#381 IHCTD9 on 03.30.16 at 12:59 pm

Maybe I’m different. I don’t care if someone posts angry and hateful stuff. That’s reality, that’s humanity, and censoring it does not make it go away. I disagree with many posters on many topics, but I like the opposing views to temper my own. Every now and then I take a little tidbit of wisdom from others, and incorporate it into my own views – sometimes even those leftwingnuts make a good point, or see things in a way I am not predisposed to do on my own.

As others have said, haters gonna hate – fill your boots – no one really cares. IMHO, an open anonymous internet forum shows humanity in its most raw, unabashed, unapologetic form. It’s more real than anything out there anywhere else. If you’ve ever wanted to know what’s really on peoples minds, come on over to the GF comments section.

If it were me running the show here at GF, the commenters would have to tolerate extreme opposing views. Don’t feed the trolls, they won’t hang around long. Maybe I’d make it so you’d have to log in, and you could block other individual posters’ posts from view if you can’t stand to look at them.

There is a difference between honest anger and the inappropriate expressions of same, and wholesale attempts at making trouble for entertainment purposes. These folks just out for giggles would be banned as required – that is pretty much it.

#382 Carol Bery on 03.30.16 at 1:03 pm

I only started reading your wonderful blog a few months ago, my kids are in their late 20’s and you are helping me guide them. Please stick around. I have seen property values jump, both in the 80’s and the last 10 years. I also saw them fall – a lot. I know you are right.

#383 Jocelan Tracey on 03.30.16 at 1:03 pm

Shut the comments. Keep the blog.

#384 Smoking Man on 03.30.16 at 1:09 pm

There is a difference.

True Feminist
http://www.cbc.ca/news/jian-ghomeshi-marie-henein-lawyer-interview-1.3510762

True Feminazi
https://youtu.be/GVuK44kWgxk

#385 Ponzius Pilatus on 03.30.16 at 1:12 pm

Garth,
For Smockie’s sake keep the blog going.
Without this blog, he may actually sober up.
The horror.

#386 lisa on 03.30.16 at 1:14 pm

Thanks for all you do, Garth. I’ve learned so much from this blog over the years and I really appreciate that. I’ve long ago stopped reading the comments section of every blog and news site. what the h happened to Canadians? We used to be so nice. :o(

#387 Ontario Doc on 03.30.16 at 1:20 pm

Garth. I rely on your blog both for some daily entertainment and for what has been sage advice. You also cut through alot of the hyperbole of the media to the facts of issues. Please don’t stop. Even my wife enjoys it and like you “she who must be obeyed” has strong input into my work life. The small minded real-life challenged vitriol spewers will have won if you quit. Many will lose.

#388 Jane on 03.30.16 at 1:22 pm

Haven’t posted in a long time but I’m always reading your blog. Like others have said, maybe consider turning off the comments for a while, or forever? I know I visit for the articles not the comments section anyways, but if you do decide to shutter the blog, I just wanted to thank you for this post you did after I emailed you quite a few years back: http://www.greaterfool.ca/2011/08/24/this-madness/

Thanks for all you do, we ditched our real estate and even started investing in ETFs because of you and are much happier and more balanced financially for doing it!

#389 Carlos on 03.30.16 at 1:22 pm

Please don’t shut it down Garth. I’ve been a lurker for many years, just reading it became an addiction, don’t let the crazy people discourage you. For each one of them there are hundreds of readers that would be sad if you stopped it.

#390 Tristan on 03.30.16 at 1:23 pm

Hi Garth,
I stumbled onto your blog about a year ago. My wife and I both really enjoy reading your posts and bantering about them. We don’t read the comments or comment ourselves, but this is a good time to pipe in and say that whatever you decide to do, we’ve appreciated reading it over the past year. So thanks for that.
Cheers,
Tristan

#391 Calgary Rip Off on 03.30.16 at 1:28 pm

Garth best post ever.

The internet allows anonymous postings so you really get to see what goes on in most people’s heads. And it isnt pretty.

I work with many rats. Most are female. Get this, at my job, if there is a late call, and the shift ends at 7:30, my unnamed female coworker, 16 years my senior DEMANDS that I have her called in to finish the procedure, even that means paying her three hours at double time, instead of paying me say an extra 20 minutes at double time. If the situation were reversed, I would expect the same, because ethics matter.

What I have found is that most people are rats. You would expect people older than you to behave ethically. Not so. And as far as people venting and playing the victim, if they think they are victims, they are. So their self talk is all wrong. I wouldnt blame you for not posting their nonsense. Your choice.

For me, I have my coping tools to escape from this pathetic planet. This morning I got out of bed, warmed up with two sets of 385×8 on deadlifts, then 425×2, then 425×3, then 495×1. No grips, no belt, and no chalk. Just the basement and me. Then I ate breakfast. Then I drove to work to the hospital. After dealing with estrogen all day, I get to return and do heavy front squats and in between sets move pieces around the chess board. Given that it is my 44th birthday today, its fitting that my wife said not word to me before she left for work. Such is typical female behavior. But it isnt enough for me to go gay, because I dont fly that way.

Other coping tools: Loud shredding on my left handed stratocaster aka Yngwie Malmsteen, readings on finance and investing, reading on plumbing and electricity, Church(yes Im Mormon one of the last real places where men can be men, thank you Joseph Smith), poker online and occasional wife affection(maybe once a year if Im lucky).

Tune out all the loser victims Garth. That’s the majority of the population, so it wont be easy.

#392 WYYC on 03.30.16 at 1:34 pm

Thank you for all the time you spent writing for us. I learned a lot about Canada, markets and economy.
It will be a shame to not have your opinion and ideas perhaps if people have to use their Facebook or LinkedIn account they may moderate their tone. If it is becoming too much hurdle please close the comments but not the blog.

Again thank you for sharing your knowledge and ideas.

#393 Ponzius Pilatus on 03.30.16 at 1:37 pm

Myself, a teutonic immigrant, and my Chinese born wife have been subject to regular racists slurs and discrimination.
As far as we are concerned it’s not end of the world.
What does not kill you, makes you stronger.
To the naive Canadians out there who believe that Canada is the land of milk and honey:
Wake up and smell the racism.
It’s not just in Europe or the Arab world.
It’s here right under the carpet, where we swept it.

#394 Notsonew Garth Fan on 03.30.16 at 1:43 pm

Like so many others are saying, yours is the best source of guidance out there. I’ve made dramatic changes in my thinking, spending, and saving since I started reading your blog daily several months ago. It’s had a concrete positive impact on my life, and with the admittedly baby steps I’ve taken, will continue into my retirement years as I reap the benefits of what I’ve learned from you. Its an invaluable source for someone like me who is neither starting out in life, nor about to retire.
I do find value in the comments – the constructive ones, not the offensive but totally understand your point. If you ever want a volunteer moderator, you have but to ask.

#395 Loving the Sun in AZ on 03.30.16 at 1:50 pm

First off, I would like to thank Garth for the financial advice that has been provided on this blog over the years. It has helped me significantly.
On the topic of mainland Chinese & HAM in Vancouver, I have a hard time understanding all the anger and resentment. I was born and raised in Vancouver so I’ve seen first hand the insanity that has been going on in the real estate market pretty much since the late 90’s (just prior to HK returning to China). Combined with the limited number of high-paying jobs available in the tech sector, this provided me with the motivation to find a job in the U.S. with a world-class company. I couldn’t be happier now. Gen-X’ers and Millenials: why not take steps to improve your own situation rather than whining and complaining all the time? Find another job elsewhere, make money, improve your standard of living, and be happy. The world is your oyster!

#396 Stephen Happier on 03.30.16 at 2:03 pm

Garth. I’ve been reading your blog for the past six months and truly appreciate what you have to offer. Unfortunately haters have hijacked it as of late to spread their hate messages. Shut them out and continue with your good work of helping others. Please keep this blog going.

#397 For those about to flop... on 03.30.16 at 2:03 pm

ICHTD9 at 364
I will probably be joining the ranks of the part time, OTS, Kijiji/Ebay manufacturing

/////////////////////////

Hey Trackie ,we have spoken before about the second hand market and how my wife and I sell our stuff in U.S dollars.

Well eBay sent us a message a couple of days ago and now as of June you can only sell in CAD apparently.
As my wife said,no big deal we will just raise our prices.
I just hope we never have to pay taxes on that money but I guess if we did we would just pass it onto the buyer like you do with the shipping.

Happy selling…

///////////////////////////

Also thanks to LP,Sean Clearwater and a few other for the GAP support.
It was introduced over the Xmas holidays at another time of turmoil on the blog( generational war) as a way of saying ,I might have a handle but I come in peace and a 68 year old woman in Ontario (Linda Pearson) is probably going to have a different view of Canada as a 41 year old male from B.C.
It might not change anyone’s view but it at least tries to help you see the world through their eyes for a few seconds.
I was housebound just out of the hospital on NYE and I was tapping away on the blog to take my mind of the pain as my wife sat beside me she asked who are talking to on NYE and I said matter of factually ” I’m talking to a 68 year old woman from Ontario ” and she smiled,because she new I bought in the GAP code to help us understand each other a little easier.

Thanks Linda and gang…

M41BC

#398 Miss Liz on 03.30.16 at 2:06 pm

Don’t go, Garth!
I need you when I get home to my lovely rental unit with a fist full of realtor flyers from the mailbox.
I need you after family dinners filled with home equity anecdotes. And I especially need you after every housewarming I attend east of the DVP.
Whether it’s reassurance I’m not crazy, a funny mutt, or sound investment advice, every day around 6pm you give me something of value. Thank you!

#399 Bitter much? swallow your bitter pill on 03.30.16 at 2:08 pm

Bitter Much?

You are one ignorant mf to use racist slang like stanted etc when the first migrant Chinese who built the railroads etc had to fight for every right including the right to vote. You want promote racism and hatred towards your own. You can make your point intelligently without using racist innuendos. I think you are not of Chinese origins b/c you should be disowned.

Owning a house is not a right. It is your desire and who says that all your desires get fulfilled. You are like a child who is throwing a tantrum b/c you can’t get what you want. Grow up. Talk to the billions of people on this earth who can not own. Go to a poor country where annual wages is in the less than $5000 and homes in the hundred thousands.

#400 Dups on 03.30.16 at 2:10 pm

It will be boring without this blog. No blog comes close to this one.

#401 Roial1 on 03.30.16 at 2:10 pm

The idea of closing down the comments is a good one.
Your blog is insightful and informative.

AND,

Please try for some more centered political insights.

I know that you have been a life long “Progressive Conservative” but, they are gone. It is now a defunct organization so time to move on. Please judge Mr. Trudeau with a more even sight.

If he really screws up, OK! get him, but if not at least wait to see just what the results of his choices of policy are rather that bashing in advance just out of your political views.

Conservatives screw up too.

Like , What ever happened to our 5 million taken by “lien Brian”. After all, he was caught? (given as an example of only one transgression by past “Cons.)

John Diefenbaker killed the Canadian aircraft industry all by himself. For political reasons. (Conservative).

Other than that, thanks for your incites into investing and home ownership.

That “rule of 90” should be required study in all schools in Canada. (especially in economics class)

#402 Cyrus on 03.30.16 at 2:10 pm

Hate to say this, but much of my modest knowledge of finances is from this blog (Rob Carrick’s newsletter is good too, but it lacks the photos). Do whatever it takes to keep the blog up and your sanity intact, please!

#403 joblo on 03.30.16 at 2:11 pm

Hey Garth, if you decide to shut the blog down can you write another book?

Guaranteed it will be published way before Smoking Man’s.

#404 Sunshine on 03.30.16 at 2:13 pm

I am reading your blog daily even on vacation. Always looking forward to your next post.
Prior to finding your blog I had no knowledge of investing. Now I have balanced, diversified portfolio. All ETFs.
I feel thankful to you because you saved me financially. I was lucky to discover this pathetic blog just when I were thinking about buying new house.
Please continue with it. There are so many of us that appreciate what you are doing.
And by the way, I emigrated to Canada 20 years ago.

#405 Sean on 03.30.16 at 2:16 pm

I’ll echo all the rest. Keep the blog going Garth. You have definitely helped many of us by keeping a consistent, level headed approach day after day, year after year. I could take or leave the comments as they aren’t really the easiest to keep track of and read. The like/dislike or report function that a lot of sites use could ease your load on needing to read each and every comment that comes though and make it easier for us to read and comment between each other. Or just stick to writing your posts and leave it at that. Glad you have the sense to know you are doing something worthwhile to help others and not shy away from your message.

#406 Melissa on 03.30.16 at 2:29 pm

Garth,

My name is Melissa, I’m one of those millenials you talk about in your blog! One of the overeducated fools that still lives in their parents basement lol In the years I’ve been reading your blog I’ve never commented but I had to now. This makes me sad, all this hate. Shame on you people. I look forward to reading your blog, its real, its educated me, made me think about whats important in life and whats not. So often i’ve recommended this blog to my 20 something year old friends who think buying a house right now in the great T.O is the best investment in life. Your blog spits the truth in so many areas, and there are people out there including myself whose lives you’ve impacted and helped. What im saying is thank you. If you decide to shut this down, it would suck. So please if you can keep going!

Sincerely
Melissa

#407 Little Foot on 03.30.16 at 2:35 pm

Hi Garth,
I’ve been an avid reader for the past # of years, first time poster because of today’s blog. Keep doing what you’re doing! It’s important and many people value your input. As for the comments that made you consider shutting down this blog, here’s a suggestion: We all know a troll is a troll; We all know, everyone is a big tough guy or tough girl behind the internet; so for the sake of your sanity, perhaps changing the format and having real names posted will help dissuade the negative posters? I’m sure that’ll change things quite quickly, especially for the trolls.

#408 Smoking Man on 03.30.16 at 2:36 pm

Like I said, what ever green companies Wynee and T2 fund, short them.

http://www.breitbart.com/london/2016/03/30/curse-of-delingpole-worlds-biggest-green-energy-company-collapses/

#409 jess on 03.30.16 at 2:38 pm

Philip Oltermann in Berlin
Wednesday 30 March 2016 12.18 BST
revealed how the press cooperated with the nazi’s
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/30/associated-press-cooperation-nazis-revealed-germany-harriet-scharnberg
————————————-
http://www.warmuseum.ca/cwm/exhibitions/propaganda/collection_e.shtml
http://collections.museedelhistoire.ca/public/objects/common/webmedia.php?irn=5379

UK plans to track all internet connections could cost £1bn, campaigners warn

Home Office is told its plans in the snooper’s charter to retain web browsing history of all British citizens for 12 months would cost in excess of £1bn

#410 Graeme on 03.30.16 at 2:39 pm

Noooo! Don’t pack it in!! I do disagree with you about the US being in recovery, but that’s a minor detail (ha!) and there’s no love lost really!

I read this blog daily because you are, for the most part, wiser than me and a great Canadian.

Why not disable comments or switch over to something more formal (eg. facebook login). There’s a time to care what anonymous people think; now is not that time. Some folk are angry and it’s going to continue getting ugly for a while. Don’t try and ride this out and be a hero. Please keep writing but stop trying to moderate or you’ll get divorced, go insane and end up ranting on some blog somewhere too. I wouldn’t want to see that happen. It’s not just you even CBC.ca has had it and they’re changing their comment process. Remember, you’re just one man.

#411 jess on 03.30.16 at 2:40 pm

Now a vast cache of leaked emails and documents has confirmed what many suspected about the oil industry, and has laid bare the activities of the world’s super-bagman as it has bought off officials and rigged contracts around the world.

Exposed: The company that bribed the world

A massive leak of confidential documents has for the first time exposed the true extent of corruption within the oil industry. At the centre of the investigation is the Monaco company run by the jet-setting Ahsani family.

Read more: http://www.smh.com.au/?reload=true#ixzz44PfSUBKO

#412 salonist on 03.30.16 at 2:44 pm

don’t know if you can live without the adulation
it’s tempered your soul,you choose
god, the double smoked kelbassa man,gone, what of.

linda put the coffee on

#413 waiting on the westcoast on 03.30.16 at 2:44 pm

#383 Smoking Man on 03.30.16 at 1:09 pm
“There is a difference. True Feminist
http://www.cbc.ca/news/jian-ghomeshi-marie-henein-lawyer-interview-1.3510762

I watched the interview – she is so on point. People need to read/learn before spouting off.

Like I said yesterday, I had to bash a millennial because of the National Bank report. She came back with… You don’t live here (which I do)…

#414 Blacksheep on 03.30.16 at 2:47 pm

Garth,

You already have 98 % of the commenter’s sucking up to you, with most (not all) thinking about themselves and how your blog ending, would affect, them.

I will take a different tact. I’m going to tell you what I think, is in your best interest.

Had a convo at Easter with my Father in law, turning 75 this year. Has diabetes. Dude was buff right up till his late 60’s and then just started fading fast.

Quite sad really.

If I was as old as you (I’m 52, your 67) and had your coin, I know I wouldn’t be wasting my prime years censoring a bunch of bitching losers.

You’ve done a great service for the masses, turning domesticated Cattle into Dogs with teeth, so you owe nobody, anything.

Like the FIL said:

“Your gonna blink and before you know what happened, you’ll be were I am today.”

Life is too short, live it accordingly…

#415 waiting on the westcoast on 03.30.16 at 2:59 pm

BTW – my YoY March is sizing up well in the US. 2 operations in the Northeast trending up over 25%, 3rd one dropped by 10% but had a massive March last year. My west coast operation is up near 20%.

Will provide the gamut in ~2 weeks when the entire system reports.

#416 Freedom First on 03.30.16 at 3:13 pm

#383 Smoking Man

Fan #33 here. Great post Smoking Man. You are a genius.

#417 tj on 03.30.16 at 3:18 pm

Garth, don’t quit. You could rest, write your post even once a week, close the comment section once it reaches 100 or at any time you feel like (tired, need a break), but don’t quit. Don’t make the bad guys happy that they managed to ‘shut you up’. You’re too brave for that. You’ve guts and a knowledge to prove that you are right. You don’t need to be perfect, nobody is. And there’re powerful forces deciding sometimes how the economical events happen. Hard to predict, especially these days. I’m just a common sense guy, about your age. Been many places, lived in a few Countries (English is my third or is it forth language?) and seen a lot and can’t believe how long the stupid RE bubble continues in our good otherwise Country. I see always simple solution to economy even on a global scale: PRICK ALL BUBBLES NO MORE TROUBLES. Even this late in the game… and we would still return to the old good days. Am I a dreamer? But who got guts to do it? Not our leaders. No wonder guys like Trump getting so much support… not mine of course, but simple folks are tired of all manipulations and lies in the media. So we need more guys like you who are not afraid to say the truth publicly.

#418 Lou on 03.30.16 at 3:25 pm

Hi Garth –

Long time reader, this is my first post, due to your blog yesterday. I am compelled to share my thoughts.

Your blog is educational and entertaining – thanks for all of your hard work, creating great content and faithfully providing a great service to all of us. You perform a wonderful service and you are a great Canadian!

Ignore the hate and spiteful comments – hard to do, easy to say. Some people should be ashamed of themselves for the vile comments they post. The price of freedom of speech.

Please keep up the good work – we, the silent majority, are truly grateful for your contribution to our financial well being.

You do good work, Garth!

#419 ts harpoon on 03.30.16 at 3:29 pm

Garth,

Moderate the haters. This blog is very important to me.

TSH

#420 Michael on 03.30.16 at 3:48 pm

Well said – regardless of the world I tend to be in I do enjoy sitting down for 10 minutes a day and reading through your blog; so please for the sake of us who enjoy your wit and banter please keep er’ going.

#421 barb on 03.30.16 at 3:51 pm

Please Garth keep your blog going!
I’ve finally gotten H to read it every day.
And if you knew that he NEVER BEFORE sat in front of a computer screen, you’d realize what a coup that is.
Really.

And, yes, delete those hateful commenters’ messages.
Thank you.

#422 NTH on 03.30.16 at 3:54 pm

I hate to put you to work with more moderating; in case this is my last chance I just want to offer a very sincere Thank You to you and your Spouse.

Perhaps some Self-care might be in order?

Best Wishes & Many Many Warm Blessings on your next adventures!

Not Tonight Honey

#423 paul on 03.30.16 at 4:01 pm

Gee, I logged on to the blog saw 413 comments.

I thought the world had ended!

#424 Dan on 03.30.16 at 4:01 pm

Canada is a racist society like any other.
Role of the state is not to speak in the name of voiceless, but to defend the nation (in this case English and French
because the rest are tourists). No single Jew was allowed to Canada during Holocaust but hordes of war criminals were allowed after WWII, because they were skilled workers, no? Now I am not gonna to talk about Native Canadians because that is disgrace. Also everything is rigged to community support so if you have no community (means your race or your nation), you perish. Emigrants come here like refugees in hordes but like professionals, few. Now, Canada like an idea of humanity and freedom, of enriching people destiny is a good idea and will survive on long run but confusion rules the world today everywhere.
So if you are tired and demoralised by your fellow Canadians, go ahead take your ball and play at home.
DO IT. Personally I think capitalism sucks but I am afraid to visit Scandinavia because I am to old for another disappointment….

#425 JuliaS on 03.30.16 at 4:29 pm

Even if the foreigners are bringing money into Canada and inflating housing prices, that’s a good thing, because the money spreads through local economy and gets locked up in real estate that at some point is guaranteed to implode, leaving those same foreigners holding the bag. You’ll be able to buy their assets for pennies on the dollar.

That’s money out of their pockets and into yours.

Garth says homebuyers who rent the properties out end up subsidizing renters. If the money is indeed foreign, then foreigners are subsidizing Canadians and in my book that’s a good thing.

#426 IHCTD9 on 03.30.16 at 4:31 pm

#396 For those about to flop… on 03.30.16 at 2:03 pm
ICHTD9 at 364
I will probably be joining the ranks of the part time, OTS, Kijiji/Ebay manufacturing

/////////////////////////

Hey Trackie ,we have spoken before about the second hand market and how my wife and I sell our stuff in U.S dollars.

Well eBay sent us a message a couple of days ago and now as of June you can only sell in CAD apparently.
As my wife said,no big deal we will just raise our prices.
I just hope we never have to pay taxes on that money but I guess if we did we would just pass it onto the buyer like you do with the shipping.

Happy selling…
___________________________________________

Interesting, I’d be a little careful with ebay. My potential plans are a little fab work and local sales. I can fab and machine, my employer has anything I could ever need free to use anytime, so something like this is a natural fit.

Make no mistake though, government agencies are trolling both Kijiji and Ebay. I’ve already gotten an auto call “from OMVIC” insinuating I was a curb-sider because I had a few too many ads on Kijiji. Their bots harvest telephone numbers, and if yours shows up too many times, you get the “scary call” LOL!

#427 Gramps on 03.30.16 at 4:33 pm

Thank you
Love your blog
Rarely read comments
Wouldn’t miss them but would miss blog

#428 Gramps on 03.30.16 at 4:35 pm

Maybe that’s why they have just a “like” button on some presentations

#429 waiting on the westcoast on 03.30.16 at 4:54 pm

Interesting comment on the financial post about the quality is data from the National Bank report on foreign RE purchases…

“Since there is no real information, the $12.7 billion figure is shaky, based on what the bank admits is a “back-of-the-envelope” workout derived via a hypothesis around a survey applied to an inference from estimated Chinese purchases of U.S. residential real estate. Even assuming $12.7 billion is accurate, what purpose would be served by taxing it out of the provincial economy?”

http://www.financialpost.com/m/wp/news/blog.html?b=business.financialpost.com/fp-comment/terence-corcoran-welcome-to-b-c-chinese-homebuyers-and-your-money-too&pubdate=2016-03-30

#430 chapter 9 on 03.30.16 at 5:24 pm

Hey Garth, if you feel like you are at the end of your rope, tie a knot in it. Forget off hand which president made that statement,hang in there!!

#431 For those about to flop... on 03.30.16 at 5:32 pm

Boss ,been thinking about how you start your days and this song from the 80s kept coming into my head.
I will post the song too if I can find it.
Peace.

It’s mainly the second paragraph.

M41BC

“Reckless”

Meet me down by the jetty landing
Where the pontoons bump and spray
I see the others reading, standing
As the Manly Ferry cuts its way to Circular Quay

Hear the captain blow his whistle
So long she’s been away
I miss our early morning wrestle
Not a very happy way to start the day

She don’t like that kind of behaviour [2x]

So, throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless
Throw down your guns
Don’t be so

Feel like Scott of the Antarctic
Base camp too far away
A Russian sub beneath the Arctic
Burke and Wills and camels initials in the tree

She don’t like that kind of behaviour [2x]

So, throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless
Throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless

She don’t like that kind of behaviour [2x]

So, throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless
Throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless

Throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless
Throw down your guns
Don’t be so reckless
Don’t be so… reckless
Don’t be so…

#432 Ainters on 03.30.16 at 5:35 pm

Haters going to Hate, Ain’ters going to Ain’t

I ain’t going to let the haters win. Joining together and accepting new people, and ideas is what helped make us strong and free to begin with. As for the racist messages, no need to share the hate.

We are (can be) better than this.

#433 TRT on 03.30.16 at 5:36 pm

Wow. Garth will never shut down this blog…support is just to huge.

Having said that, I can differentiate the racist comments from the non racist ones. Those on here that conclude the non racist comments are racist basically stifle discussion.

And believe me when I say this, I was one of a few visible minorities in my school growing up. And experienced racism from my own teachers.

#434 For those about to flop... on 03.30.16 at 5:41 pm

This is the song about being reckless, which a few of us are with words sometimes as well.

Slow for the first 1.5 minutes and then gets going.

M41BC

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=JIrUqsB-0vw

#435 sm_yyc on 03.30.16 at 5:45 pm

Hi Garth

consider modifying the comments section to be linked to facebook or any other social networking site that can verify the poster’s identity. This way you will not see all the hateful, racist and disrespectful comments everyday.

this probably has already been suggested to you. keep writing :)

#436 John on 03.30.16 at 5:46 pm

400+ comments. Good guys win.

#437 Gerry in North Toronto on 03.30.16 at 6:24 pm

Garth, we are all lucky that you have Dorothy to pull you back from the brink. Many, many balanced Canadians enjoy your humour and banter. Many also benefit from your views and perspective. Thanks for the huge effort to educate and entertain us.

#438 Blacksheep on 03.30.16 at 6:32 pm

Lots of suggestions to kill the comment section.

IMHO, your blog with out the colourful (not racist) comments, would be boring.

Human interaction is what this is all about.

#439 lee on 03.30.16 at 6:44 pm

Who audits the OTPP books? How can it be making 13% a year?

#440 Harbour on 03.30.16 at 6:47 pm

When my post the other day that never made it to print about this blog being a waste of cyber space…. I mean’t the useless comments

#441 Bytor the Snow Dog on 03.30.16 at 6:48 pm

@380 IH Guy- Very well said.

I’m trying to figure out WTF things are coming to. People are “triggered” by words on a blog?

Really?

#442 Buy Low Sell High on 03.30.16 at 6:54 pm

Garth,

I have a suggestion. You could continue to write this blog and permanently eliminate the comments section. Then, some other web designer could start a new blog called Greater Fool Comments Blog and all the lunatics could ‘ave at ‘er! How about that? No more moderating racist and sexist that consume several hours of your day.

#443 Chris on 03.30.16 at 6:54 pm

Great post. Good on you!

#444 common sense on 03.30.16 at 6:54 pm

Yesterday’s post and today’s lack of post remind me of my dear late mother…

Usually once a year she would get fed up of being not appreciated for all she did for our family, vent ,and go on a 2-3 day strike…no cooking, cleaning, etc. Would leave the house at 8am and return after supper…

Yes we got the hint she was appreciated and yes we feel the same about you…Hope your enjoying your time away Garth, hopefully knee deep in Tequila and enjoying a fine night or 2 out.

#445 Ryan on 03.30.16 at 7:03 pm

This better not be it Garth, I’ve been waiting since 3pm Pacific time..

#446 acdel on 03.30.16 at 7:03 pm

Totally off topic but an interesting read due to the fact that I have expressed my opinions on Garth’s choices on a previous post.

Take a look at the oil break even point: Not looking so bad for Alberta now; in a couple of years things will get back to normal; hopefully not as crazy as before but a nice long steady growth.

http://business.financialpost.com/news/energy/fragile-five-these-opec-producers-are-on-the-verge-of-collapse-if-oil-prices-dont-stabilize-soon

#447 Joe2.0 on 03.30.16 at 7:08 pm

Got to digest that altumatium.

#448 Susan on 03.30.16 at 7:09 pm

I’m one of the people you’ve helped. Thank you!

I also enjoy most of the comments.

Really, really don’t want to be “last”.

#449 Sparky on 03.30.16 at 7:25 pm

Garth

I can completely understand you shutting this blog down, I would have by now if I didnt need to do this, which you obviously do not.

It’s a shame that the spew that is all over social media and comment sections of blogs and newsites has found its way in here and threatens to ruin it.

I stumbled upon your blog when I was looking for generators and information on just being prepared. I think it was around 7 years ago, and I have been reading you ever since.

I read your blog because you present some high quality information on how to structure your personal finances, learn how to recognize and deal with risk, and how to sift through the endless piles of crap out there on money and investing. Your blog presents a very humbling, realistic, and witty outlook on an important subject that we should all be aware of, and at no gain for you. This is something to be applauded for, not harassed with.

My wife and I have been following your models for financial structure (which we are adopting our own way of doing), and I can tell you it has changed our financial picture 180deg for the better. The people reading this blog should be utilizing it for what you intended it to be!

But, once again, the rest of the class has to ruin it for the rest of us!

If you do pack it in, I appreciate all you have shared and wish you all the best.

Thank you.

S

#450 Herb on 03.30.16 at 7:29 pm

First, Garth, congratulations on a new record number of comments. I have been wondering what to write since last night, which is an indication in itself.

I joined your army on 18 October 2006, the day Harper turfed you, and I dare say that you have not had a more loyal soldier. However, I started to pull back when you jumped the shark of objectivity after “socialists” were elected in Alberta last April. Then the election of an untested leader of a Liberal government made it worse. You, and a lot of commenters, had nothing to measure the new governments against except ingrained ideological yardsticks. The result is an ideological moshpit that might be enjoyable to the converted, but is a piss-off to those not drunk on the applicable Kool-aid.

You have surrendered control – anyone can post anything, whether relevant or not, whether germane or not, as long as no one could consider it to be hateful or racist. Does anyone know what “hate” and “racism” really mean, and whether those terms actually would apply to the published comments decried as such? We have reached that happy state of public discourse in Canada where criticism can be silenced by the slander of one word.

By coincidence, my wife also has suggested that I stop wasting time here. I have been tempted for months to throw in the towel, but hate leaving the field to assholes who have no facts or reason to support opinions but push them vehemently anyway. Or use this blog for presumed personal enhancement.

It’s your blog, your decision, and your rules, but I would recommend that you regain control or concentrate on your daytime job. If “Greater Fool” is to be a fair of information and ideas instead of personal and partisan vanities, post only comments that are on point, relevant and germane. Forget the gong shows and personal attacks. They contribute nothing to democracy or financial literacy.

Do you really want to be the publisher of a blog combing the tone and truth value of “Member’s Statements” and “Question Period”?

#451 gut check on 03.30.16 at 7:46 pm

I have no dog in this fight. For the record I think the influence of offshore ‘hot’ money is something we ought to be talking about and there’s NOTHING racist about it. Now that doesn’t mean that some people don’t make it into a race thing, because some people certainly do.

I do want to respond to this:

#24 A man about a dog on 03.29.16 at 6:24 pm

“I had a message for the readers. There are very few places on the web that you can go to get advice without being sold something.
…../snip
So to all the bitter blog dogs. If you want someone who will tell you what you want to hear and confirm your bias. There are plenty of them out there.”

You’re being sold something here, just maybe not what you think. You’re being sold one side of the story. Be honest with yourself about that at least.

And if you can’t be honest with yourself about that then the second paragraph you wrote which I quoted above is moot. Or at least, it’s over your own head.

#452 Bee on 03.30.16 at 7:50 pm

Dear Garth,

We have been reading your posts for 5 years and have never commented before. So, we are writing today in hopes of being added into the pile of comments that will sway you from ending your posts or at least to let you know how much we appreciate you and all that you do in case you retire your posts in spite of us hoping you dont. 5 years ago we were relocated to Vancouver and were thrown into the insane real estate market there and were faced with having to spend about $1,300,000 for a tear down home in a bad part of town. As we work extremely long hours, we cant live too far away form the core. The best way to express our emotional state at the time was first panic, heartbreak, denial (thanks to the bank) and then a combo of all three . My husband was 50 and I was 43 and we had been home owners for decades. We had gone to our bank (TD) to crunch the numbers and “Front Branch” would not qualify us for enough to buy even a 2 bedroom condo. They set up a mobile mortgage broker from “Back Branch” who came out to our branch and sat down with us to put together some creative financing. He asked my husband what his “Busiest biggest earning year” was to date and punched those numbers into his laptop and then asked me what I was currently bringing home. At that time I was not working. I told him this and he said “no, if you working, what would you be making.” He entered the amount I gave him and then gave us the amount that the bank was willing to lend us to be able to afford to buy in YVR. ($1,500,000 on fake income) We were shocked. We had thought the Canadian Banks didn’t practice this kind of fraudulent banking. We, were wrong. With our realtor pressuring us by bombarding us with the usual tripe about how “if we didn’t buy now we would never be able to because prices would keep going up”.
After weeks of house hunting and trying to shove the sick feeling we carried around because we were terrified about being our age and taking on such a massive amount of house debt we were beyond stressed out. Rent is so high there due to the high house prices. Well, one day we were at an indoor playground with our daughter and we started chatting with another parent and we came around to the topic of whether or not we were renters or owners and it came up that we were house hunting. He starting talking about; You. We, listened. We had a line up of homes to see with our realtor the next day and when we got home we pulled up your site and read from inception on. Late into the night, after many good laughs and some major epiphanies’, we looked at each other and thanked the Gods that fate had taken us to that biological infestation of an indoor jungle gym on the very day and the right time to run into and chat up an avid Blog Dogger who helped lead us to “Garph” (as our 5 year old at the time called you as she had not yet achieved the use of her “th” sound yet.) To this day, in our home, you are called “Garph”. We of course cancelled our house hunting and felt so blessed that we had stumbled into your world. We are so grateful that you dedicate your time, brain and the worst part, your skin; to helping others. Without you and this site we would have ruined our lives. We knew it felt wrong but you showed us why. You showed us the truth and woke us up from our hazy dazed stupor and we are so thankful. We have also sent many others to your site in hopes that it will help them too. And they pass it on and so it goes. Yes, your sense of humor can be off colour and even sometimes offensive to those that take political correctness to the max but, we love it. No one is making anyone read your posts or forcing them to agree with what you have to say. I would imagine that the comments that are hateful and nasty are very hard for you to have to read day in and day out. That over time they would drag you down. That they make you start to feel like you no longer wish to be exposed to or wish to provide a platform for them to expose their ugliness others. We too would rather see you post and not have comments than go silent.
However, you have been putting yourself out there for years and how could anyone blame you for wanting to step away and start a new adventure. Some day and maybe even soon, People will say that you were not wrong about your predictions, just…early. With Gratitude.

#453 Bottoms_Up on 03.30.16 at 8:29 pm

830pm eastern and no entry from the divine one…Garth please stop scaring me!!!!

#454 Nice Man on the Net on 03.30.16 at 9:41 pm

Please don’t quit, love this BLOG.

I need your commentary on demographics & housing

RENX article: http://renx.ca/millennials-still-interested-buying-homes/#.VvrMMtcOU3w.twitter

see national bank: reckless households, https://www.nbc.ca/en/rates-and-analysis/economic-analysis.html

#455 Only 4 comments show?! on 03.30.16 at 11:48 pm

It says 454 comments, but only 4 show. Could this be a software bug at your end?

You seem to be correct. I have asked the webmaster to investigate. — Garth

FIXED:caches cleared, some settings checked, all good
— Webmaster (12:48 am March 31st)

#456 Iconoclast on 03.31.16 at 10:54 am

Garth, you are doing Good in this world. Please continue.

I think crowdsourcing comment moderation would save you a lot of clicking.

#457 Ken Lovegrove on 03.31.16 at 11:01 am

Hi Garth.

I do think there should be more transparency when people post. I mean if you have something to say then people should not hide behind a pseudonym.

The fact is people will be less abusive if we actually know who they are.

Posting hateful emails anonymously is cowardice.

Keep up the great work.

#458 Travis on 04.01.16 at 3:50 pm

Keep it up Garth. As an Australian that has immigrated to Canada I absolutely love how you cut to the chase and tell it how it is. People are too sensitive. You’re not and it’s refreshing. I love it. Maybe send all the email address of the ‘unlikeables’ to the spammers. Plenty of websites out there that would LOVE their email addresses :)